Add this

Friday, 13 November 2026

CAN INDIA RECLAIM ITS POLICE FROM POWER, POLITICS AND IDEOLOGY ?

 Any dispassionate and objective observer of India would have surely noted the decline of India's public institutions, both constitutional and statutory, over the last decade. I speak here not of their performance (though that too is a matter of concern in many cases), but of their waning independence, increasing politicisation, non-adherence to their mandate, lack of accountability and sensitivity to public concerns. And at the top of the list of such bodies is the Police, more particularly in the north Indian states, the Hindi heartland or the cow belt, which now also includes Assam, Bengal and Odisha, unfortunately.

This has to be a matter of particular concern for all law abiding citizens, because no other institution touches the public more directly than the civil police: it is the first port of call for any citizen coming in contact with the law, it has the power of using sovereign physical violence, it can deprive one of personal freedom, it can enmesh anyone in years of legal troubles. 

The police is today the primary agency through which this government functions, because this regime does not believe in democratic institutions or practices- consultation, advice, dialogue, persuasion or public perception; the only medium of administration it knows is FORCE. Therefore it has to rely on the police, and that is where the deterioration begins. A uniformed force committing transgressions and excesses on behalf of the government soon becomes immune to the rule of law, and functions like a law unto itself. It turns rogue and becomes as unaccountable to the government as the latter has become to the people. The two develop a parabiotic relationship, one to stay on in power, and the other to exercise its now unfettered power for its own agrandizement. This is what has happened to the Indian police over the last decade or so, especially in some of the northern states. Encounter killings, custodial torture and even deaths, indiscriminate arrests, demolitions, forcible evictions, illegal deportations, voter suppression, selective prosecution, mentoring of criminals, excessive use of force (the July Jantar Mantar protests)- all these have become the norm now. Jama Milia, Kathua, Hathras, Lakhimpur Kheri do not make news anymore.

The Indian police had never really lost its khaki, colonial tinge, but its retrogression under the present governments, both central and states, has been rapid and alarming. There are three clear indicators of this.

One, excessive use of force and curbing of civil liberties and rights, often beyond the mandate of law, without any accountability. Examples of this are the brutal use of force on protesting youth on 20th July this year in Delhi and Bihar, the large scale registration of cases and arrests in the NE Delhi riots in February 2020, most of which have failed to stand judicial scrutiny subsequently, physical persecution and prosecution of those who protest against environmentally destructive projects such as bauxite mining in Niyamgiri in Odisha or the Siang HEP in Arunachal. Encounter killings have become the norm in some states: according to official NHRC data, in six years from 2016 to 2022, there were 813 encounter deaths but no conviction of any police official. Custodial ( judicial and police) deaths also occur in frightening numbers: once again, NHRC figures show 1606 such deaths in the year 2021-22, while the MOS (Home) informed Parliament on 26th July, 2022 that there were 4484 such deaths in the two year period of 2021 and 2022. "Bulldozer justice", demolitions of religious structures and houses of suspects and accused, arbitrary imposition of NSA and UAPA, arrest for alleged "conversions", forcible deportations- all these have become a sickening and daily reality, notwithstanding repeated warnings and strictures by the courts.

Which brings us to the second indicator of the deterioration of the police forces: contempt for judicial orders and judgments. The most recent example of this was the ignoring of even Supreme Court orders during the Delhi protests: in spite of clear directions from the court, the Delhi police continued to detain lawyers and journalists, shut down Metro stations and roads, obstruct the peaceful protests. (The court is now hearing a contempt case on the matter and both the Delhi Police Commissioner and Union Home Secretary have filed apology affidavits). The position is even worse in some other states where High Courts have repeatedly been passing strictures against the police. The Allahabad High Court, on November 3 this year, while accepting a habeas corpus petition, stated in an order that "Civil liberties situation in U.P is shameful: Police have little regard for citizens' rights." It went on to scathingly observe that "the infringement of these rights seems to have become a matter of routine for the UP police." Similar observations have been made by other courts from time to time but these have not deterred or restrained the police from continuing with their lawless conduct. Regrettably, the reluctance of the courts to go beyond strictures has only encouraged this growing tendency.

The third indicator, perhaps, provides the reason for this flagrant disregard of orders, laws and the misuse of authority and physical force. It is becoming increasingly evident that some sections of the police are now sympathetic to, and fully support, the Hindutva ideology of the ruling dispensation, and therefore have a personal animus towards those who do not. This explains their brutal use of force on protesters, the pellet guns and AK47s, the targeting of even women journalists, even the reported sexual manhandling of young girls at Jantar Mantar. It also explains their willing targeting of members of a particular community in  myriad cases. It is difficult to believe that they would have been ordered by their superior officers to commit these selective excesses as part of their SOPs, though I would not be surprised if that was indeed the case. (It may, however, not be fair to single out the police for this dubious honour, considering that even the higher echelons of the bureaucracy, defence services, universities, and judiciary seem to have espoused the ruling ideology.)

Further- let us admit it- the police as an institution is dominated by the upper castes. Even though affirmative action by various govts has improved the representation of Backward castes, Dalits and Scheduled Tribes, at 51% their share is still far below their 67% share in the general population. The misogyny in our police forces is explained by the fact that the share of women is only 10% against their 48% share in the general population. Muslims account for only 4% (excluding Jammu and Kashmir) though they are 14.2 % of the general population (2011 census). These are precisely the sections of society for which the ruling ideology does not give a tinker's curse.

These figures go some way in explaining why a certain ideology is gaining traction in the police and dictating their actions. India is a highly divided society, the personnel of the police emerge from this society and carry their biases and prejudices with them. When these negative influences are further given free play (if not encouraged) by the political executive, the result is what has been described by the Allahabad High Court and quoted verbatim in para 6 above. The cost is paid by the average Indian citizen and society as a whole in the quality of governance and state of the justice system.

The greater danger, however, lies in the future, in the question: when the good times, and the equitable rule of law,  return, will the police shed these decomposition of values, the increasing malfeasance, perversion of their mandate ? Or have these become so embedded in their psyche that they will be impossible to dislodge? Even more disturbing: will succeeding governments, even though of different persuasions and dogmas , even be interested in reforming the police? For power is a communicable disease, and the virus needs little time to spread from one host to another.

Saturday, 7 November 2026

THE CHANGING FACE OF GLOBAL TOURISM

 Even as global tourism continues its relentless growth (1.52 billion in 2025 and growing at 4% per annum), the opposition to its environmental, social and cultural impacts is also increasing (except, of course, in India where your typical North Indian tourist continues to carpet bomb the Himalayan states with plastic, beer bottles, condoms and uncouth behaviour). Therefore, I was gladdened to learn that, in other countries at least, new forms of tourism are emerging, which are environmentally sustainable, respect local cultures, customs and traditions, and reject the bucket-list, itinerary driven form that currently prevails. They give better value for money, are more meaningful, relaxing and even therapeutic. I give below some of the new versions which are being embraced by more people, especially the younger generation. 

FOREST BATHING (or LAND SNORKELLING)                                                         Immersing oneself in a natural setting; quiet walking, no talking: this is the best form of meditation, it reduces stress and improves the mood.

NOCTOURISM                                                                                                   Night tourism, both amidst nature and as city tours. Gives one a new perspective of our world and includes night safaris, star gazing, constellation tracking. A survey in Tokyo (500 million tourists every year!) found that 67% of them booked night tours.

TOWNSIZING                                                                                                   Getting off the beaten track, away from the hustle and bustle, noise and congestion of metros in favour of small towns and villages to experience the authenticity and charm of a laid back lifestyle that is now almost a thing of the past. Preferred increasingly by Gen Z, it is also known as QUIETCATIONS and HUSHPITALITY, and is meant to counter corporate burn-out and digital fatigue.

JOMO ( JOY OF MISSING OUT) TOURISM                                                                 The opposite of FOMO (FEAR OF MISSING OUT) in today's digital world. Prioritizing oneself, doing and experiencing what YOU want instead of following the herd and keeping up with the Joneses. The opposite of group or chartered tourism.

SLOW TRAVEL                                                                                                 Rejecting the rushed, itinerary based, tour guide dictated form of mass tourism in favour of a more slow paced experience, a deeper involvement with the places visited. Staying longer at one place, understanding its culture, traditions, cuisine, people, rather than rushing from one "must see" hot spot to another. (The average tourist at the Louvre in France gets to see the Mona Lisa for just ten seconds before s(he) has to make way for the next in line!). Much more personally fulfilling and one comes back refreshed.

SLEEP TOURISM                                                                                             This may come as a surprise to readers, but it makes sense when one learns that 100 million Americans do not get adequate sleep! In this genre, the top priority is to get a good night's sleep for a few days, to detox and cut one self off from the demands of daily urban existence. A survey by the Hilton group of hotels revealed that two thirds of their guests sleep better in hotels than in their own homes. Hotels cater to this need by providing special mattresses, dimmed lighting, sound proofing and a Do Not Disturb ambience.                    REGENERATIVE TOURISM                                                                             When travel begins to heal as well as energise. Spas are the usual offering in the developed world, but in India a different model is gaining popularity- Wellness tourism, created around Ayurveda, Vipassana, Yoga and traditional Indian medical practices. This has existed for some time in states like Kerala, but of late Himalayan states, with their unique mountain climate, geography and pollution free ambience are also cashing on this. A rapidly aging and health conscious population provides a good catchment area for customers.                DARK TOURISM                                                                                                 Sadly, there are revenue making opportunities available even in human tragedies, and Dark Tourism is their product. It involves visiting sites of conflict, accidents and other tragedies. Initially prompted by a desire for closure, seeking both understanding and emotional resolution (Jalianwala Bagh, the Union Carbide plant in Bhopal, World Trade Center in New York which receives 40000 visitors a day, the Holocaust Museum), it has now assumed macabre dimensions: hundreds of Zionist Israelis have been visiting the front-lines to witness the bombing, shelling and destruction of Gaza in real time.     PREGNANCY TOURISM                                                                                    This may sound freakish, but it exists and is a by-product of geo politics and poverty. It involves pregnant women going to certain countries to deliver their babies, in order to exploit the "jus soli" (citizenship by birth) clause which is part of the immigration laws of most countries. In the USA about 320000 babies are born to mothers who are either illegal immigrants or are there on temporary/tourist visas. That constitutes 10-12% of all births in the USA. No wonder Trump has been trying his best to change the laws.                               A version of this is rumoured to exist in Ladakh too, though no evidence of this exists. It is claimed that women from Europe (especially Germany) come to the Aryan valley where the Brokpa (aka Drokpa) community live, to conceive from local males. The Brokpas are said to be descended directly from the soldiers of Alexander's army and have pure Aryan blood. (Similar claims are made about the residents of Malana village in Himachal's Kullu district). The idea is to have pure Aryan children. Geneticists are not even sure of this, and for all we know this may just be a ploy to boost tourism to this valley! 

It is, however, heartening to note that more and more people are beginning to realise the value of nature, authentic indigenous ways of life, the benefits of a slower pace of life, the importance of leaving behind a smaller ecological footprint. Maybe we in India will wake up to this also one day.




Friday, 30 October 2026

ERRANT THOUGHTS ON REGIME CHANGE AND PEACE BONDS

 The more discerning among my readers would have noticed that in India the flavours of the season change with, well, the season. In July it was the humble cockroach, in August it was the foot-in-the-mouth Chief Justice of India (again), in September it was the redoubtable Tukaram Mundhe. Come the cold edge of October, and the flavour has changed again- it is now "Regime Change." The chill in the air is not due to the approaching winter alone.

This is the new four-letter word these days. Every Whatapp Unkle and Anty  are  talking of nothing else. BJP spokespersons whose English hitherto extended only to "What goes up your father's?" (Tere baap ka kya jaata hai ?) and darbari anchors whose IQs are lower than their TRPs can't get enough of it. The phrase is being tossed around on prime time TV every night like a piece of dung at a dung beetles' convention. It has replaced the Original Sin in the BJP/RSS playbook, and I have no doubt that the BNSS shall be amended very soon to make it a crime, in the company of sedition and treason. Expect the Supreme Court to approve it speedily, for a regime change there is also being talked about in hushed tones.

In most countries regime change would mean a change of government, but not in the mother-in-law of democracy where we don't do things by halves. Here I see multiple regimes being targeted for replacement- the government yes, but also the Election Commission, the Supreme Court, some media conglomerates, the Rasputins in the RSS, the two Gujarati double-engines driving our economy into the billionaire Valhalla, the spurious satraps installed in states by Gyanesh Kumar, the Presiding Officers of our two Houses which now resemble, figuratively speaking, a Gujarat bridge after its collapse. For it has taken a huge cooperative effort to bring this great country to its knees and the credit for it must be generously spread, like the subsidised butter in the Parliament canteen.

To prevent this, the diabolical duo are moving heaven and earth, ITBP and CRPF, Solicitor-General and Judge, Arnab Goswami and Padmaja Joshi, IAS renegades and IFS turncoats, Kangana Runout and Smriti Irani, Sanju Verma and Anand Ranganathan, even goons and parole convicts. But it doesn't appear to be working, for it's not just the cockroaches who have had enough, it's also the dimagi naxals, the urban Naxals, the "gutter generation", the "Khalistani" farmers, parasites, termites, maybe even a bhakt or two who have discovered that their God has feet of clay and knees of jelly when it comes to mentioning China. There's a complete menagerie out there which Vantara would be proud to possess. No amount of pest control measures can get rid of these pesky critters, it appears.

In India, the last resort of wannabe despots and usurpers is no longer politics- it is the Law, which is why it has now been decided to weaponise the "Peace Bond". Initially intended to keep the peace, it is now being employed to keep the power (of the chosen few, of course). The new international border is in Jantar Mantar and Connaught Place, not in Ladakh or Arunachal Pradesh, and so tens of thousands of troops have dug in in our cities. The Chinese and Pakistanis can wait- we  have to save the country from its own citizens first. Meanwhile, if you want to step out of your house or wave the national flag or shout "Give us back our Vote" or take a leak in a public toilet, you first have to sign a Peace Bond, giving an entirely new meaning to RIP. You either rest in peace or are arrested in pieces.

Which leads me to an interesting thought- if citizens can be asked to sign  bonds for keeping the peace (whatever that may mean), then why not ask the minions of the state to sign similar bonds for doing their duty? Like: the Delhi policemen signing a bond to not sexually molest young girls, judges to deliver judgments based on law and not on their future prospects of reemployment, MPs/MLAs to pledge that they would resign if they change parties, Arnab Goswami to stop repeating that crap about "fearless journalism", political parties guaranteeing that they would implement their pre-election manifestos, and so on. THIS would be the real swadeshi amendment to the IPC, not the garbage drafted probably in Nagpur. It would not make India a Hindu Rashtra, of course, but would definitely do much for better governance. And it is the type of bond one could support, at Jantar Mantar or Central Park- when they are notified again as protest sites, of course. I'd be willing to sign a bond for that.

Sunday, 25 October 2026

THE G-124 LETTER HAS LET DOWN THE CIVIL SERVICES

 Connoisseurs of humour know that all genuine humour is underlaid with wisdom, which provides the actual punch. And so it was that, when I read the recent open letter issued by 124 retired civil servants defending Gyanesh Kumar and his nefarious doings, I was reminded of the sage words of Maurice Switzer: "It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt."                                                                                            I was not surprised by this epistle, however, for my Whatsapp groups have a dense population of such bureaucrats, closet members of Mr. Modi's tribe. What did surprise me, however, is that for once they chose to speak out (on the wrong side of history, yes, but they did come out of their burrows), because such people are more comfortable in the security of the woodwork and like to hedge their bets. They do not rock boats, they never take a stand, they always worship the rising sun, and they know which side of their bread is buttered. I suspect they were persuaded to say "Aye" by Mr. Modi's gentle persuaders- a few crumbs, loaves and charge-sheets might have been traded- to sign on the dotted lines (not difficult, for it is something they have done for most of their careers).

A word about the signatories to the letter would not be out of place. Most of them are faceless wonders, which is as it should be since their faces have egg, if not worse, all over them by now. A couple have been accused of embezzlement and corruption; one displayed his bigotry and misogyny brazenly at an event in a ladies' college some time back; yet another, now a Chancellor of ,a central University, has been an acolyte of the BJP for a long time; some are working with right-wing organisations like the Vivekanand Foundation and ORG, one is on record stating that he has issued orders under political pressure! Not exactly the kind of "concerned" citizens who can be trusted to objectively comment on the doings of this regime and its puppets like the Election Commission. In short, their credentials are highly suspect.

The letter itself is a manifesto of the ignorant and a charter of obsequiousness. It praises the Election Commission of India for its "historical" achievements (which, needless to say, belong to the past and not the present dispensation), supports SIR as a much-needed exercise, condemns those who are asking for Gyanesh Kumar's resignation, and backs Modi's regime to the hilt. (It has to be the hilt, because they have impaled themselves upon this sacerdotal sword in true hara-kiri style.) The windmill this G24 is tilting at is clearly the letters issued earlier by another group of civil servants, the CCG (Constitutional Conduct Group) which has, over the last ten years, established a sterling reputation for  taking a principled stand on many issues where it felt the government had violated constitutional values, rights and provisions. Maybe the heat was getting to someone in the kitchen?

I shall not try to counter and expose the fallacies, downright untruths, lack of logic and distortion of facts in the G124 letter: that has already been done very ably and comprehensively by MG Devasahayam, a senior retired IAS officer, with facts and figures in an article in The Wire (Ex-civil servants defending SIR are wrong) on 16th October 2026.

Nothing, however, proves how wrong these letter writers are than the conduct of the Election Commission itself over the last few days since the second round of protests in Delhi. It has practically admitted its guilt and culpability in the SIR fiasco. By gradually (and quietly) rolling back and reversing some of the draconian and illegal provisons of this exercise of exclusion it has validated the charges against it. Just to recapitulate, in the last couple of weeks it has taken the following decisions:

* The mischievous declaration attached to Form 6 has been removed.

* Access to ECINET has been restored for the EROs (but not yet, strangely, for the Tribunal judges in Bengal!)

* A technical Committee has been set up to audit the suspect ECINET software.

* It has admitted that the two Election Commissioners had indeed written to the Cabinet Secretary about the irregularities in the body.

*A cap has now been imposed on the number of infamous Forms 7 which can be submitted by one person.

*A special drive has been started to include the left out/deleted voters in the states where SIR has concluded.

* In the 17 such states an SSR (Special Summary Revision) has been initiated, to enroll voters who have turned 18 and had been left out of the SIR.

*Machine readable voter rolls in pdf format shall now be provided to all candidates.

*List of deletions/additions shall be provided to all political parties.

* The ECI has implicitly admitted that it does not have any list or details of Amit Shah's "ghuspaitiyas" or termites (the oft stated reason for SIR given by Gyanesh Kumar) among the 130 million deleted voters.

This is as comprehensive a guilty plea as any ever submitted by any accused to any court. For these actions/ information was precisely what the the entire Opposition and civil society activists had been demanding for months but the imperious Gyanesh Kumar had been refusing to provide, instead ordering the LOP to furnish an affidavit first! His admission now strengthens the belief that all this was done (for the BJP) to win the elections in Bengal and Bihar. Wait for that admission too, as the noose around the ECI tightens. 

Finally, the G124 letter is not a legitimate expression of differing views or free speech, as its apologists may claim. It is an expression of support and encouragement for authoritarianism, intolerance, electoral cleansing, denial of fundamental rights and exclusion, and no civilised nation can countenance this kind of rhetoric. It is dangerous for democracy and the rule of law. It has tarnished the reputation of the civil services. For, at the end of the day, any one who supports wrong doing is just as guilty of it as the prime mover himself. In the words of Nelson Mandela, in an appeal to his people issued from a prison cell:

"Will you come along with us, or are you going to cooperate with the government in its efforts to suppress the claims and aspirations of your own people? "

The people of India deserve an answer from this rump of civil servants.

Thursday, 15 October 2026

AN APPOINTMENT NOT GIVEN, A TRUST FORFEITED

 The Chief Justice of India refused to meet the Leader of the Opposition on the 12th of this month and hear his grievances, even though one of his predecessors had no problems about inviting the Prime Minister to his residence for a pooja and a cosy tete-e-tete. This snub was both unfortunate and expected.

Unfortunate, because the CJI is not another divine, non-biological being but a part of the system. This system has become dysfunctional,  and the LOP simply wanted to convey this to him. The LOP has as much of a constitutional status as a CJI, even though their roles differ. The CJI would not have compromised his much vaunted, but increasingly doubted, political "neutrality" if he had had the courtesy to meet the LOP, listen to his grievances, perhaps accept a memorandum or two, share a cup of tea, and bid him "Auf Wiedersehen" or "We shall meet at Phillipi." No one expected him to act on the grievances, of course, since many of them pertain to his own court, but at least the window-dressing of democratic accessibility and an "independent" judiciary would have been preserved. It might even have restored some of the trust that large sections of the public no longer have in the Court.

But, as I said, the refusal was expected, for the simple reason that the Supreme Court no longer has the moral authority and people's trust to act as an honest broker (or arbiter) between the government and the Opposition/ public. It had started shedding this constitutional teflon long before Justice Suryakant's tenure, beginning with its orders on Rafale, Pegasus, Hindenberg, Ram Mandir, Electoral bonds, Umar Khalid, to name just a few. But the molting has become more pronounced over the last year or so. There is a perception that it has been consistently  siding with the executive and Election Commission in spite of scientific evidence, ground realities and public demands: it gave a clean chit to the use of EVMs, made a statistical mockery of the VVPAT verification, ignored the selective use of the Model Code of Conduct in favour of the ruling party, stayed silent at the dubious rejection of nomination papers of opposition candidates (which has now been upgraded to blatant intimidation and arrests), the use of police to "persuade" some voters to stay at home during polling, turned a blind eye to the egregious change/delay/ mismatch in voter counts, looked on  as the Election Commission repeatedly approved the breaking and hijacking of opposition parties and governments by the BJP, preferred humiliation to contempt action when the Committee set up by it to select the CEC was thrown into the dustbin by the Modi govt. Each and every mischief of these types was brought to its notice through various petitions (which, the CJI reportedly told Rahul Gandhi, was the kosher way of approaching the Court !), all usually rejected with the contempt they deserved or put on the backburner for a more propitious time. In fact, the Court occasionally even frowned on those who filed these petitions and wasted its time, drawing upon its vast knowledge of zoology to term them cockroaches, flies etc.

The nadir was reached when it did nothing- NOTHING- for over a year to reign in an election commission which had gone rogue with its brutal SIR (Special Intensive Revision) which has consigned 130 million voters to the twilight zone between statelessness and deportation. Worse, it greenlighted the politically partisan exercise in May this year, incentivising the ECI to redouble its efforts to rob the Indian citizen of his fundamental rights. Therefore, now that massive protests have erupted all over the country against SIR and the CEC, the public appears to have lost confidence and trust in the Court, forcing it to march on the Court itself, a first in our history. To put it bluntly and unkindly, it is now seen as a part of the problem, not of the solution.

With all gate-keepers of democracy and justice- the higher judiciary, Parliament, Election Commission, National Human Rights Commission, the media - abdicating their constitutional duties and oaths and becoming irrelevant, India's citizenry has occupied the space that genuinely belongs to it, and which no wannabe despot can take away from it: India's roads, streets, parks, open spaces. Here too, the Supreme Court has not exactly covered itself with glory: it suggested removing Jantar Mantar as a protest venue,  initially failed to take any action against against the Delhi police for its excesses on the young protesters, including girls, journalists, advocates, passers-by, students. When public and international outrage finally forced it to issue some directions, these were hedged with so many caveats, conditionalities, escape clauses like "in accordance with law", "provided", and "however," that the police treated them as cosmetic inconveniences. As I write this they continue to beat, detain, sexually manhandle, protect their hired goondas, shut down half the city. Today, a one-stripe constable at Jantar Mantar effectively wields more effective power than the Chief Justice Of India- or so it seems to most citizens.

THIS is the background and context - the total breakdown of law and order, denial of constitutional protections and rights, evisceration of the values of democracy, subversion of institutions, the rampant use of sovereign violence, the defiance of judicial orders - in which the LOP wished to meet the CJI on the 12th of this month. The Supreme Court is the last port of call for the citizens of a failing ship of state, and it does not behove the Chief Justice to  wash his hands of the mess by saying "Law and order is not my domain." Yes, in normal circumstances it is not, but when the pretext of law and order is used to suppress the people's voice, to inflict needless violence. to shut down a city, to deprive citizens of their basic rights, to murder democracy itself- where else can the people turn to for legal redress but the Supreme Court? Such a moment is not the time to split hairs about "administrative" and "judicial" side, as the CJI has sought to do; he should look at the "justice" side. For, in the ultimate analysis, if the highest court in the land cannot assure justice for the citizens, it becomes another legal fiction and might as well be wound up. The Constitution has given the judges of the higher judiciary extraordinary powers, privileges and protection, to safeguard the rights of the people, not the government of the day. If this authority is instead used  to allow authoritarian over-reach, then this is a breach of the trust the people have reposed in the Court, a violation of a sovereign contract, and they- We The People- have the inherent right to enforce accountability and even demand resignations. That moment in time has arrived. 

The Hon'ble Chief Justice should have given the Leader of the Opposition an appointment. It was the latter's right and the former's duty. It was also, perhaps, a democratic nation's last call to remain one, in a peaceful manner.

It's still not too late to do the right thing, Your Lordship. Otherwise, to take a phrase from the Bible, On your own head be it.

Sunday, 11 October 2026

THE UPSIDE OF BEING A DODO

                              THE  UPSIDE  OF  BEING  A  DODO


 As I find it a little more difficult to get out of bed each succeeding autumn morning, my mind  (what's left of it, that is) inevitably wanders to thoughts of ageing. The process is very gradual and kind of sneaks up on you: the cells stop multiplying but continue dividing, not unlike the BJP, the telomeres stop communicating with each other a-la Mr. Gyanesh Kumar and his colleagues the joints protest loudly like Mr. Kejriwal at any sudden move, the memory starts playing tricks like it does frequently with Mr. Rahul Gandhi on the stump, and one begins to speak like Sashi Tharoor i.e. in words that no one understands, certainly not my sons, nephews and nieces weaned on the two syllable patois of Twitter and Instagram. So slow is this process, however- like being murdered by a  four toed sloth- that one is not even aware of it.
   And then one day- WHAM!- it suddenly hits you full on the geezer. It can happen in different ways- getting up in the morning feeling half dead and having to check the obituary columns to determine whether one is still alive or dead, that alarming ECG report when you take out that new health insurance policy, the moment when your son is blessed- is that the right word these days?- with his second child or third divorce. It can even happen as it did to Groucho Marx: you are standing grieving at the graveside of your batchmate, all alone because everyone else has left, when a chap sidles up to you and whispers: " Not much point in going back home, is there?" My own epiphanic moment, however, came in an entirely different and discomfiting way.
   I usually travel by Metro since I need to reduce my family's carbon footprint which rivals that of Bigfoot or Godzilla, thanks to my wife Neerja. I seem to have spent my entire life following in her trail like an excited puppy: earlier it used to be so that I could spoon up the random smile, the casual word of endearment, the fleeting expression of affection- all too precious to be left discarded by the roadside. Now, however, I do it so that I can switch off the fan, lights, AC, geyser or heater in her wake: she NEVER puts them off because God himself once said " Let there be light!" and she's a deeply religious person. She HAS to say hullo to her mom, sister and bevy of friends six days in a week, and- you guessed it- it can't be done over the phone because Airtel maytell everyone about it, and in any case they all have to see who is wearing which type of Banarsi saree that day. So she burns the hydrocarbons like Mr. Mohammad bin Salman is giving it away for free in order to atone for blowing away Mr. Khashoggi, not a recommended use of wind power.
   So here I was on the Delhi Metro one day; it was crowded and I was standing in the aisle hanging on to a strap like yesterday's washing. Suddenly a pretty young girl got up from her seat and offered it to me with the words( I shall remember them till my dying breath): " Uncle, please take the seat." UNCLE ! When a beautiful member of the fair sex calls you Uncle you just know that there's no point in going on living; it's the kiss of death and you now belong with the dinosaurs. It was at that exact epiphanic moment that I realised that I was now a prime candidate for the geriatric ward. I had boarded the train as a sprightly 75 year old, but deboarded at Mandi House a broken relic. My metamorphosis was complete: I now belonged to the ages.
   One year later, however, after twelve months of this fossilized existence I must concede that things are not all that bad: being a dodo has its upside. I no longer mind the aching joints when I wake up every morning because they indicate that at least I'm still alive. The best thing about getting old is that all those things you couldn't have when you were young you no longer want, and therefore don't miss them any more. I no longer fret and worry where my wife goes of an evening, just so that I don't have to go along with her. Mrs Sitharaman gives me an additional Rs. 50000 exemption on my income ( before he mops it all back with incessant cesses, of course), and the Railways give me a concession on the fare even though the train is 12 hours late and/or cancelled. The govt. respectfully refers to me as a "senior citizen" before asking me to line up for four hours in various queues. And most important of all, I'm gradually moving out of that lethal " MeToo" zone which has felled many a perpendicular stalwart, if you get my drift. Though, if accused of molestation, I might well be tempted to follow the example of that zippy 81 year old who was recently accused of doing just that. Standing in the dock he could barely conceal his pride at having been conferred this honour at his age, and when asked by the judge, pleaded guilty! The judge, of course, was having none of this and fined him a thousand rupees for lying under oath ! Or that other old dodger who was approached by this hooker outside a bar who propositioned him thus: " Hi, dad, I'm a great believer in barter: what do you say to some sex for some beer?" The ancient geezer thought for a long moment and replied: " What kinda beer you got?" Ah, the arrogance of old age! As Oscar Wilde almost said: the young know everything, the middle-aged suspect everything, and the old don't give a damn about anything!
   And that, dear reader, is the problem with the kiss of death: you're dead but don't know it. The walking dead.

 

Monday, 5 October 2026

INTERVIEW WITH KARAN THAPAR- "THE LAST SKY."

 I was interviewed to day by Karan Thapar on my new book THE LAST SKY- COUNTDOWN FOR AN ENDANGERED PLANET. I am giving below the Youtube link to the interview for those who may be interested in viewing it.

 https://youtu.be/qIDDTooeYqg

Sunday, 27 September 2026

CONVERTING A STATE INTO REAL ESTATE.

 

[ A slightly shorter version of this blog was published in THE TRIBUNE on 27.09.2026 under the heading HOW LOOPHOLES ARE CONVERTING A STATE INTO REAL ESTATE].

In response to a recent blog of mine about unregulated constructions in Himachal, a discerning reader commented that he had done an online search for available properties in the state, and to his horror, found that 23450 properties were advertised for sale/ rent/ lease between just Shimla and Narkanda, a stretch of just 90 kms or so. Even allowing for double counting, these figures tell a tale which our policy makers would do well to listen to, and heed. For what they tell us is that faulty policies, lack of vision or understanding of economics are making Himachal prime real estate, up for grabs by whoever has the money and connections to exploit the system. But some background first.

Land is a precious commodity in Himachal, for the utilisable land is less than 15% of its geographical area- 8 lakh hectares against a total of 55.67 lakh hectares, the rest being forests, "gair mumkin" or areas above the tree line where nothing grows; the actual area under agriculture is even less- just about 5.25 lakh hectares. Farming is almost at subsistence level, the average land holding is 0.94 hectares (in Punjab it is 3.64 ha), small and marginal farmers hold 89% of the arable land. Industry is almost non-existent and the state has one of the highest unemployment rates in the country. For all these reasons , as Nirmanyu Chauhan and Divyanshu Thakur put it so eloquently in their article in the WIRE (8.3.2026), land in this state is not just a commodity, it is a source of dignity, livelihood and autonomy. And security.

Himachal's first Chief Minister, YS Parmar, had the vision to realise this and therefore took steps to ensure that Himachalis were not deprived of their lands by rich and exploitative outside elements; he brought in the Tenancy and Land Reforms Act in 1974, Section 118 of which imposes severe restrictions on non- Himachalis buying land  in the state. They can do so only after obtaining prior approval of the government. Subsequent Chief Ministers, sadly, have lacked the same foresight and have introduced so many exemptions and loopholes in the law that now any smart lawyer or purchaser can buy any extent of land in the state for any purpose. And this is happening on a colossal scale, as the Shimla- Narkanda figure in para one proves. In just the last three years 1494 approvals have been granted, but this is only the proverbial tip of the ice-berg, the real mass of the problem lies below.

The actual transfer of lands to, and purchase by, outsiders would be many times the number of approvals officially cited above. This is because of the many exemptions provided to the operation of Section 118: no approval is required for a society consisting of agriculturists, flats built in urban areas, houses/flats taken on lease, RERA approved builder developments. These exemptions are actually loopholes and have virtually thrown up the whole of Himachal to land sharks and builders. In addition, "benami" land transfers are another way of avoiding the rigours of the law.                                                                                                 As living conditions in north Indian cities and metros steadily worsen, more and more people there are now investing in second homes in places like Uttarakhand and Himachal, especially post Covid. The threat now is to rural Himachal and its original residents. Land prices have sky-rocketed, and the Himachali landowner, unable to resist the lure of quick money, is being dispossessed of his ancestral lands on an ever increasing scale by hotels, home-stays, builder developments, resorts. This is changing the very architecture of the mountains, replacing green cover with concrete, effecting the demographics (as in the "ghost" villages of Uttarakhand), distorting local cultures. At risk is not only the geology but the very identity of the state.

                    


         [Flats for sale in Barog. Recreating the hills in concrete.

         Photo Credit: The Tribune]


The state's policy makers must look at the long term implications of such land transfers; it is time to review Section 118 of the HP Tenancy and Land Reforms Act to make it more restrictive. No approval should be given under this section for construction of hotels and  resorts in rural areas- they are ruining the hinterlands (just as they have the cities), one has only to visit the Tirthan valley, the Jalori pass to Jibhi stretch, the once pristine Barog saddle, the Mashobra-Naldehra section to see for oneself how pastoral Himachal is being converted into a concrete mess of multi storeyed structures There should be a complete ban on Section 118 approvals for real estate developments, housing societies, multi storey apartment blocks or villas. All the existing exemptions/loopholes in the Act need to be reviewed, especially the ones pertaining to RERA projects, purchase of flats, and leases. Some new curbs need to be introduced in the law, for example, a ban on purchase of lands belonging to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and BPL families (as in Uttarakhand) to prevent their exploitation by deep pocket outsiders and land sharks. Except for specific projects approved by the government, non-Himachalis who wish to purchase land in the state should be required to establish some connection to the state, whether by way of service, business or family for a minimum number of years, to qualify.

There would, of course, be legal considerations involved in adopting this course of action. There is bound to be resistance from some panchayats as land values will drop, from politicians egged on by land dealers and real estate companies, from the builder and property dealer lobbies, from influential people in the metros looking for a piece of the mountains as their own premium condos are engulfed by pollution and civic  collapse. Fortunately, the HP High Court at least has grasped the gravity of the matter; in a recent order it has castigated the government for allowing the concretisation and denudation of the green cover of Barog. It has sought details of approvals accorded under Sec.118, sanction of building plans, number of trees felled on private land, and has even warned that it would not hesitate to order an investigation by the CBI.                  Anyone who loves Himachal and its peoples will welcome this order, and would hope that this is the first of many to follow. The government should stop playing politics and making money, and should realise that this is a matter of survival of the mountains and the people to whom they belong. The state cannot be allowed to become one huge resort or gated community.


Friday, 25 September 2026

ROLL OVER, BEETHOVEN ! (and RSS)

 All the signs of the Second Coming, as foretold in the Bible, are visible: wars and conflicts, natural disasters, lawlessness and moral decay of society. Increasingly, however, it would appear that the event shall happen, not in Bethlehem or Palestine, but in India. A new God is about to be born here. The omens and clues have been there for some time: the presiding over the "sengol" in a new Parliament, the displacing of the Shankaracharyas at the inauguration of the new Ram Mandir in Ayodhya, the Shivji type of meditative posture in a Kedarnath cave, the non-biological claims, the direct communion with the Gods. And if anyone still had any doubts, the recent birthday celebrations of the prime candidate for the job should dispel them like tear gas at Jantar Mantar. He was worshipped like a God incarnate by the faithful, the powerful, the 37% of the country who have been ideologically lobotomised, "diyas" lit for his long life, "bhajans" sung in his praise, I believe even temples erected for his eternal exaltation and glorification.

It appears to me that the stage is set for a new religion,Moditva, to replace Hindutva. The latter has served its purpose: religions must evolve to suit the zeitgeist of the times, new Gods must be brought in as lateral entry to strengthen the divine cadre, the scriptures must be reinterpreted to conform to the new ruling and fashionable ideology of the head priests, the loaves of office will be the new "prasad" on offer, the hosannas will now be digitized through EVMs. These are tectonic shifts in the religious firmament, the old deities can no longer meet the new job description, their CVs are dated. A new God, a new religion are needed. Mr. Modi and Moditva will fit the bill nicely, thank you.

Expect the proselytization in favour of Moditva to begin in earnest now, notwithstanding the many anti-conversion laws that bedevil other religions.. Actually, this job is already half done with Universities and colleges, "autonomous" institutions, the civil services and the top brass of the defense forces, Bollywood, the media, RWAs, already brought into the fold; the judiciary needs a few more strategically prodded Collegium postings to be fully baptised. The rest shall be done by Apostle Gyanesh Kumar.

There may, however, be a problem with this Roll Over, RSS ! moment. Will this hoary organisation, founded on the old Hindutva ethos, simply play ball and turn belly up? Or will it see Mr. Modi's Second Coming as its own Final Going ? And is the new Godhood even possible without the RSS singing hymns and psalms to it ? These questions shall be answered, methinks, not at Phillipi , but in Uttar Pradesh next year. Till then, dear reader, join a choir and start practicing. There is much singing to be done yet.

*                              *                               *                                    *                       *               

The SIR (Special Intensive Revision) started as a catastrophe in Bihar and Bengal but has now become a farce in Delhi. India is perhaps the only country in the world (outside the totalitarian ambit) where even retired judges, an ex-Vice President, a serving Election Commissioner, Chief Ministers of states, a retired Army Chief, retired Ambassadors, a former Deputy Prime Minister, the Chief of its premier federal investigative agency-all pillars of the nation- have to prove their voter status and citizenship. Even though they have all voted in the past and have adorned the highest posts in the land! They are in the company of 4 million other Delhi voters, almost 40% of the existing voter list. Who says we are one of the world's leading unequal nations ? With his indiscriminate carpet bombing of voters Mr. Gyanesh Kumar has not only struck a blow for equity, but has also reduced our population by 130 million, as Mr. SY Quraishi has pointed out. Expect the Ministry of (Fudged) Statistics to rework our GDP and per Capita Income as an offering to the new deity.

There are, of course, many explanations for this farce. AI experts are of the view that this was bound to happen - with the Election Commission itself having gone rogue, it was inevitable that the AI agents in its algorithms too would turn rogue. Others believe that this was a false flag operation, the result of our close ties with Israel-by deliberately targeting the creme-de-creme of past and present governments, the ECI is debunking the charge that the exercise is meant to delete minorities and vulnerable sections who do not vote for the BJP. Can anything be more democratic, transparent and equitable ? A third explanation is that this is a shot across the bows for some- behave your self, or out you go from the voter roll and into Bangladesh !!  Our village idiot offered a fourth perspective- that this was Mr. Gyanesh Kumar's first move to, well, move into Rashtrapati Bhavan- a message that he holds all the cards, or votes, and that a  mere thirty pieces of silver will not do for him. But I prefer the prognostication of our hamlet's second eminence, the village drunkard who's steeped to his eyeballs with both booze and the latest news- viz. that Gyanesh Kumar, in the light of the latest developments, will be the first sacrificial offering to the new presiding deity of Moditva. He doesn't know it yet, but the cockroaches do, and they've been around for a long time, haven't they?

Which is the correct explanation? I don't know, and I really don't care. All I know is that a farce is no laughing matter. As Samuel Taylor Coleridge said: Farce is nearer tragedy in its essence than comedy is.


  

Saturday, 12 September 2026

LESSONS FROM NEPAL FOR HIMACHAL- STOP THE DESECRATION OF THE DEV BHOOMI

 Only a fool  learns from  his own mistakes, said Otto von Bismarck, the wise man  learns from the mistakes of others. It is now time for policy makers in Himachal , who so far have refused to learn from either their own mistakes or that of Uttarakhand and Wayanad, to imbibe some lessons from the horrendous tragedy of Nepal. And the lesson is simple- the Himalayas have had enough. Back off!

"Development" has gone berserk in Himachal- 12000 hectares of precious forest land diverted in the last twenty years for various projects, 174 hydel projects sanctioned/ commissioned, 5 million trees felled, construction rules relaxed to permit even 10 storey buildings, the Shimla Development Plan 41 approved to deregulate the city's precious Green Belts and allow construction even in the Heritage and Core areas, an epidemic of unnecessary four-lane highways criss-crossing the state, scores of tunnels planned under the fragile mountains, plans to increase tourist footfall from the present 20 million/ annum to an unsustainable 50 million. And all this in a state which comes under the seismic category VI- the highest. No amount of warnings or reports from environmentalists and scientists that the mountains simply cannot sustain this level of anthropogenic activities have made the governments (current and past) see sense.

The Himalayas are now pushing back, with increasing intensity. Not-so-"natural" disasters in just the three years between 2022 and 2024 have caused direct financial losses of Rs. 13500 crores to the state and claimed 800 lives; the indirect losses to business and livelihoods are much more. (Just this year the losses so far have been Rs.1400 crores and more than 200 dead).For the natural features that held the fragile mountain stratas together- trees, glaciers, snowfields, river drainage- are being decimated and destroyed by these activities. The Himalayas are warming at twice the average global rate, and this warming effect is being amplified by local "heat islands" caused by emissions from heavy machinery and labour camps, deposit of black carbon on the ice fields, pollutants from the ever increasing number of vehicles intruding into high altitude fragile eco-systems on the new roads, removal of green cover. The permafrost which holds together the fractured mountain soil is melting. Dumping of muck in the watercourses is reducing their capacity to carry the excess water, resulting in regular "flash floods." Many  red lines have been crossed.

The Himalayas have been warning us for some time now- there was Kedarnath in 2013 , Chamoli in 2021, Sikkim in 2023, Dharali in 2025, and now Nepal.      Among the most dangerous impending threats to Himachal is the growing number and size of the glacial lakes in the state, primarily responsible for the disasters above. The state had 107 glacial lakes of noticeable size with a total area of 5.54 sq.kms in 1990, the numbers are  669 and 11.20 now. Some have reached dangerous proportions, like Ghepan in Lahaul which has grown six times to almost 100 hectares. All the major rivers emanate from the glaciers above these lakes and the hydel projects on these rivers are extremely vulnerable to GLOFs. The very hydrology of these rivers are changing. Any damage to these projects would also endanger the lakhs of people living in towns and villages below them, as Nepal has so tragically shown.

Himachal is also naturally susceptible to other high risks: the state lies in the highest seismic zone- VI, it has 20000 landslide prone hot-spots, EWEs (Extreme Weather Events) caused by climate change have increased by 40% in the last few years.

The time for studies, seminars and only monitoring is over. What is needed urgently is decisive action and a drastic change in the model of development the state has been following all these years. The government needs to consider these measures urgently:

* Impose a moratorium on ALL new hydel projects, and stay those sanctioned but not yet started actual construction. Scrap the dozens of projects approved/planned for the high altitude Chenab and Chandrabhaga basin in Lahaul-Spiti, and in Kinnaur and Pangi areas (which the local people have already been protesting against for many years).

* Exhume the 2010 report on environmental impacts of hydel projects by the then Addl. Chief Secretary (Forests) which the High Court had accepted but the then govt. had opposed and subsequent ones moth-balled. Consider its major recommendations- ban on hydel projects in high-altitude, alpine, glaciated, forest catchment areas; maintain minimum distance of 5kms between projects; ensure minimum perennial flow of rivers; develop EIAs, EMPs, CAT plans for the entire river basin (and not just individual projects), before sanctioning any project on any river. Review all projects in the light of these recommendations, and if they are not conforming to them, or pose a threat, then decommission them.

* Vigorously oppose the Center's proposal for a 8.7 km tunnel below the Pir Panjal range to bring the waters of the Chandrabhaga in Lahaul to the Beas in Kullu. This project would rip out the heart of the Himachal Himalayas and would be a disaster of unprecedented proportions: it would destabilise the geology of three districts, generate tens of millions of tonnes of muck which can only clog the rivers, waterways and drainage of these areas, it would disturb the underground acquifers and affect hundreds of water supply schemes, the additional water now added to the Beas would amplify the river's destructive potential, which already causes havoc in Kullu every year. New Delhi's diplomatic failures (which is the cause for this project) should not morph into misery for the state.

* Reconsider the mindless focus on increasing tourist numbers to 50 million from the current 20 million. The state's environment cannot support such numbers, the infrastructure needed for it- roads, buildings, vehicular pollution, sewage and garbage, water supply- would result in huge damage to the natural environment and cultural identity of the state. Learn from the Bhutan model, limit the numbers, improve the quality.

* Impose a ban on tourist/real estate/commercial constructions in rural areas, especially on the peripheries of major towns. Himachal's cities have been ruined by such constructions, mainly by outsiders who are now despoiling the rural areas, cutting hills, felling trees, congesting rural roads, straining local water availability, polluting the forests and water-sources with sewage and garbage, creating noise and light pollution The areas adjoining Kasauli, Solan, Shimla, Manali, Palampur, Dharamsala bear abundant testimony to this ravaging of the environment. Himachal's rural areas should not be allowed to go the way of its towns.

* Immediately discontinue and put a halt to the four-laning epidemic, which benefits only politicians, contractors and bureaucrats.  They are not needed, they fracture the geology of the areas they pass through, destabilise the slopes, destroy properties, deprive people of livelihoods, encourage even more polluting vehicles to contaminate our pristine ambience. Both the Parwanoo-Shimla and Kiratpur-Manali highways are continuing (and very expensive) disasters that prove this. Both remain "under construction" even after a decade.

The time to act is NOW. The Himalayas have tolerated our arrogance for centuries, but their patience is now wearing thin. The warnings to us are getting more frequent, and more intense each year. We proudly call Himachal the Dev Bhoomi but ravage and pillage it shamelessly for votes and profit. This must change. Even the Supreme Court warned the state govt. some months back to be more sensitive to the environment or the state would "disappear from the map " of India. We are proving right the words of Hubert Reeves, a French astrophysicist and environmentalist:

Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible nature. Unaware that this Nature he is destroying is the God he is worshipping! 

Respect Nature. That is the true worship of God.


Friday, 11 September 2026

THE LAST SKY- COUNTDOWN FOR AN ENDANGERED PLANET

 


I'm happy to convey that my latest, eighth, book has been released yesterday by Authors Upfront/ Paranjoy. It is a book I always wanted to do, and am glad that my publishers have made it possible.

The Earth is hurtling towards environmental Apocalypse at break-neck speed, and every possible alarm is sounding. CO2e emissions are going up every year instead of declining, the planet is about to breach the critical 2* Celsius (increase in temperature) mark by 3035, 10 million hectares of forests are cut down every year and one third of the Amazon rain forests have vanished, all Himalayan glaciers will disappear by 2100, 10000 species of life forms are going extinct every year (1000 times the normal pace of nature).

 The state of India’s natural environment does not offer much hope, either. The present government’s stated policy of prioritizing “ease of doing business” over protecting the environment has led to dismantling and diluting the laws on the subject, converting the Ministry of Environment to a facilitator for industry and big capital (between 2014 and 2019 it approved 11500 cases of diversion of forest lands-99% of cases received!). Even the judicial guard-rails—the Supreme Court and the National Green Tribunal –appear to have fallen in line, as the recent judgments on the Aravallis and the Great Nicobar Project demonstrate unambiguously. More effort is spent by the government on fudging figures than on taking pro-active steps to move to a more sustainable policy.                                                                                                                                                 I will not bore the reader with more figures, the pieces in this book contain plenty of them. Suffice it to say that the present Holocene era has been  rechristened by scientists as the Anthropocene in recognition of the human-induced impact on the planet, and it may very well be the last for homo sapiens.

For things are only getting worse, for the three most powerful forces at play today which have the power to destroy the world- AI (Artificial Intelligence), Climate Change, wars -are coming together, developing a synergy which is ominous for the survival of all living creatures. The race for ever-increasing GDP numbers, unsustainable consumption and materialism, growing human populations, human avarice, greed and vision-less leadership-all mean that the planet’s natural resources are being plundered at a rate beyond its powers to replenish, and will lead to an inevitable collapse of the global eco-systems. Mankind cannot possibly survive this collapse.

Sadly, there is little interest in our country in this subject, even as the effects of ignoring it are compounding every year, whether it be urban pollution levels, increasing toxicity of rivers, falling ground water levels, melting of glaciers, emergence of zoonotic viruses, greater incidence of floods, landslides and GLOFS ( Glacial Lake Outburst Floods), changing weather patterns, heat-waves. No one appears interested in talking about this looming disaster- not the governments, media, political parties, judiciary, the dormant intelligentsia. It is never made an election issue or a public cause, except in some very instances, and then too it is quickly forgotten.

This book is an attempt to redress this (im)balance. The collection of 60 essays covers the period from 2014 to 2026, so that the reader can judge for himself the evolution of policies, impacts and urgency over time. (He will, unfortunately, find that things are only getting worse with each passing year). The essays address a wide canvas of issues: hydel projects, unplanned urbanisation, forest management, wildlife protection, rewilding, overtourism, excessive “development” in the Himalayan/ mountain states, short-sighted global and domestic policies, climate change. A whole chapter has been devoted to  Himachal Pradesh, for two reasons: first, I have served there for 35 years and am settled there and it is the state I know best. Secondly, Himachal accurately reflects the issues confronting all Himalayan states in the country.

The book has been divided into six chapters, the pieces in each covering a broad sector/ subject such as Policy Issues, Tourism, Hydel Projects, etc. The essays are arranged chronologically within each chapter, and dated, to provide the proper context for a better understanding by the reader. The purpose is not only to share information but to facilitate and encourage the reader to engage with the protection of our precious natural environment and ecology. Not just as an intellectual or academic exercise, but for a very selfish objective- to leave behind for our children a healthy, living and breathing planet. For, as someone said, this is the only planet we have, if we destroy it there’s no Plan(et) B.

(This book is available on Amazon (paperback and Kindle version) and at leading bookstores).

 

Friday, 4 September 2026

THOUGHTS ON EATING OUT , PROTESTS AND SPLIT PERSONALITIES .

 One doesn't eat out often, partly because I haven't yet received my last six DA instalments, but mainly because I can never find parking in NOIDA. But once in a while one has to be adventurous, so Neerja and I decided to have a night out. The question, however, prompted by recent FDA revelations about what is actually dished out as food in restaurants, was: how do we ensure that we are not served plastic granules as rice, palm oil as paneer, crow meat as chicken, shampoo and emulsifier as milk ? "I know," said Neerja, "let's invite Tukaram Mundhe to accompany us for dinner too!" She was right, you know-Mr. Mundhe is the new toast of the foodies, when he walks into a restaurant the rats and cockroaches (the real ones) leave by the back door, the analogue paneer is dumped into the sewer line, and managers start counting the flies in their kitchens instead of their profits.                                                                          I'm told the most sought after rating in Bombay eatery circuits these days is not the Michelin Star, but a certificate which proudly states "Tukaram Mundhe approved eatery." A close second is a board announcing: "Tukaram Mundhe eats here." But I'm afraid he may be Khemka-ed very soon: institutions nowadays are not expected to follow the law but to find ways around them, for a consideration, of course. Opposition to him has started organising itself. The Bombay High Court has already conveyed its royal displeasure to him. A report in a newspaper revealed that footfalls in restaurants have fallen by 20%, as folks no longer want to pay through their noses for dining on cockroaches, rats, flies and worms (not to mention the Service Charge). I would not be surprised if corporate hospital boardrooms are worrying about the declining patient numbers (and profits) in their Emergency wards for food poisoning, vomiting, loose motions, nausea and other complimentary gifts of five star eateries. Very soon this shall have an effect on our GST collections and the GDP, and Mundhe shall be declared a Dimagi Naxal and Pakistani collaborator. He will then be sent on deputation to the External Affairs Ministry where any damage he does will be as nothing compared to the destruction Messers Jaishankar and Misry have already wrought, and will therefore not be noticed. 

Coming back to my dinner date, Mr. Mundhe was not available on the phone: he was on his seventh interview of the day for a TV channel, after which he was scheduled to raid the Raj Bhavan kitchen. So Neerja and I decided to play it safe and have aloo parathas and kheer at Murthal- a dhaba is still the safest place to eat in India, and there's plenty of parking too. It also eases the pain of the missing DA instalments.

*                    *                        *                         *                     *

The cockroaches, Dimagi Naxals and "kuttas" are barking up the wrong tree. The changes and reforms they want -in the examination systems, condition of schools, accountability- will not happen unless this unresponsive government in Delhi departs. And it will never depart as long as the future elections (general and state) are based on SIR and EVMs. It now appears increasingly plausible  that both have been so structured as to deliver victories for the BJP/NDA  when and where it matters. The anecdotal evidence is mounting. The established political parties appear to be  finally realising this, and the new kids on the block should, too. They will achieve their ultimate goal only when the elections are rendered fair and transparent, when the Election Commission of India is compelled to cancel SIR,  revert to the paper ballot system, impartially enforce the Model Code of Conduct; when the force of public pressure persuades the Supreme Court to quash the appointments of the three Election Commissioners as violative of an earlier SC judgment. These are the foundational changes the times demand and the CJP should take up - achieve these, and the rest will follow as surely as spring follows winter. Fail here, and the winter of discontent will continue for a very, very, long time and there will be no spring.

*                     *                      *                      *                            *

I've reached the time of life when I can expect Drs. Dementia, Parkinson and Alzheimer to be standing in a queue outside my door. They have not, however, paid me a visit so far; I suspect because either my name has been deleted from their lists in a Gyanesh Kumar type of exercise, or because they suspect that I am already so far gone that their ministrations are not required. Which suits me fine, because these days I am afflicted by another condition- schizophrenia or split personality, or, to be more precise, splintered personalities because there are now so many of me. Let me explain.

The symptoms first evinced themselves in 2014 but have now metastatized to an impressive scale, especially after the July student protests in Delhi. I have always considered myself a dissident or dissenter of the Modi government and was fairly comfortable with this personality trait, notwithstanding that it has cost me most of my relatives and friends. But not any more. For I am now informed, on the authority of a dozen Ministers and Kangana Runout, that I am also a cockroach, a "kutta", an Andolanjeevi, gang member of both the Khan Market and Tukre-Tukre gangs, a gutter generation type, an anti-national, an urban Naxal, a Dimagi Naxal. Whew! That's a lot for any one individual to handle: I cannot for the life of me figure out to which of the above genera I belong. It has caused an identity crisis for me: who the Hell am I ? I probably need to see a shrink, but I don't think my CGHS card will cover that. Neerja, the only other intelligent member of my family other than Brutus, my doggo, says there is only one solution to my problem- stop disagreeing with Mr. Modi on everything and become his supporter. With this change my splintered personality will coalesce into just one - that of a Bhakt- and the schizophrenia will vanish in an instant. A Bhakt has no nuances, doubts, questions, he is self confident in his stupidity, proud of his incompleteness. I considered the idea for a couple of days but then decided to dump it. For I discovered that the "bhakt" has his own medical, much severer mental condition- Delusional Psychosis, in which he regards the non-biological one as a God, has a complete disconnect from reality, is ready to kill those who think, pray, eat or speak differently and is stone deaf to reason. I can live with my splintered personality but this "bhakti" is a pain in the traditional place I can do without. Maybe I'll just go to Sadhguru to find out the real me.

Sunday, 30 August 2026

THE RETURN OF THE INDIAN JOINT FAMILY

 The joint family was one of the better constituents and binding blocks of Indian society for centuries. Consisting of three or four generations living under one roof, it bonded its constituent families into one larger whole, sustained positive relationships, pooled individual resources into one economic whole. Socially speaking, perhaps its best characteristic was that it took care of the weaker members of the larger family- the infants, the old, the sick or otherwise disabled, the unemployed, the indigent-and ensured that they too were cared for and lived a dignified life. The importance of this last aspect cannot be overstated, for then there were no government welfare schemes, pensions, hospices or Ayushman Bharat types of protective umbrella

Looking back, I feel that my father's generation was perhaps the last joint family generation (he passed on in 2017 at the age of 93). He himself grew up in a sprawling family consisting of his parents, four siblings, innumerable uncles, aunts and THEIR families, and a couple of near invisible widows. They all lived together in happy chaos in a huge "haveli" my grandfather had built in his village in Fatehpur district of UP; God only knows how the family's finances were managed: even a firm of chartered accounts would find it difficult to untangle the various contributions to the family kitty! One word of caution, however: don't for a moment think that it was run on democratic lines- no, sir, it was a patriarchical autocracy, my grandfather's word was the law and everyone accepted it because it was a mutually beneficial autocracy. No other system would have worked half as well !

The Indian joint family started fraying, I suspect, in the 60's and 70's, and it was more or less dead by the late 1990's and early 2000's. I'm sure sociologists have identified the reasons for its gradual demise, but it was an inevitable consequence of "development" as we know it.

Things started changing with my generation, the Baby Boomers. Education, mobility, job opportunities all expanded, youngsters started leaving their homes, first for better education and then for jobs, and settled down independently in places distant from their parental houses. This trend only expanded with the next generation, the Millenials. Joint families almost disappeared and were replaced by the "nuclear" ones. Loneliness for abandoned parents became a collateral damage.

I guess this social evolution was inevitable, not only for the reasons given above, but also as a consequence of improvement in girls' education. With this, they were no longer content to let early marriage define their lives: they now sought independent careers, and their own homes after marriage. How and where couples lived was now decided, not by a patriarch, but by economics- jobs, salaries, future career prospects, and the desire to raise their own families in their own way, without any parental interference.

But the wheel is coming full circle with Gen Z, and ironically, the same forces that drove them away from the joint family system are now forcing them back to it ! More and more young adults in their late twenties and early thirties, employed and unemployed, married or single, are now coming back to live with their parents. This is confirmed both statistically and anecdotally. Research shows that 70% -80% of young adults live with their parents, as do 20% of young couples, and the trend is only growing. In my own social and family circles I find that this is true in at least one out of every two families (including my own!). This shift has not happened  because of any change of heart on their part but because of pure economic and aspirational reasons.

The reasons are varied, both economic and social. Both boys and girls are marrying later: the mean marriage age for girls has gone up to 22.9 years ( 24 to 27.5 for girls in urban areas), and for boys to 29 years ( early 30's for urban based males). Being unmarried means they continue to live with their parents. Conversely, divorce rates are going up too- since 1990, it has gone up from 1.1% of all marriages to 1.6%, low by western standards, but an increase of 50% nonetheless. Divorce means the separated entities again return to the safe harbour of their parents (especially if there are kids involved)! 

Joblessness is another reason- 40% of India's graduates are unemployed, and a large cohort of those employed are barely able to subsist on the wages they get, especially in urban areas. A new NITI AAYOG report states that 8.70 crore youth (between the ages of 18 and 29) are in the NEET (Not in Employment, Education or Training) category. They have no choice but to live with their parents. Artificial Intelligence is beginning to exert its malevolent effect: big tech companies have already cut tens of thousands of jobs and more will be on the chopping block. Real estate, whether owned or rented, has become so prohibitively expensive in even Tier 2 or 3 cities that living separately is just a dream for most youngsters. The costs of domestic house-hold support, or for child rearing are unaffordable. At these prices, even aging parents and their cluttered houses start looking very attractive, and their expertise in bringing up kids is simply irreplacable! So the joint family is suddenly back in business.

And guess what?- it suits us aging Baby Boomers too. The empty nest is full again, the creeping loneliness is banished, life acquires meaning again. It's a win-win situation: for the youngsters it provides a material safety net, for the parents it fills an emotional vacuum. But there's a catch, as there usually is in all good things!

Nature did not intend for progeny to live with their progenitors for all time. This is why adolescent animals are banished by their parents once they are taught the skills of survival and are forced to fend for themselves. Joint families are a departure from this basic law of life. Too many adults living together generates tensions, arising from a dozen differing perceptions of personal space, views and opinions, social preferences, eating habits, financial matters, etc. The joint families of my father's era resolved these tensions by having one dominant authority- the head of the family- whose word was final and instinctively respected by all.

That is no longer the case with Gen Z, Alpha and whatever other alphabetical generations are biding their turn in the womb of time. Youngsters of today are taught to question, not accept things at face value, speak their minds, not acquiesce to authority blindly. This is anathema for joint families, and I see it playing out in many families. It will need a lot of patience, understanding, give-and-take, genuine care and respect for each other for Phase 2 of the joint family system to succeed. It is still a work in progress and I really don't know how it will work out. I hope it does because families are the bedrock of any society and happy, functional families make for a stable social order, something this increasingly fractured world badly needs.  

 



Friday, 21 August 2026

BOOK REVIEW- TETE-A-TEA by INDI KHANNA

 

READING  THE  TEA  LEAVES.




For most of us tea is the cuppa that wakes us up in the morning, for the cognoscenti it is a career, but for those who are passionate about it, it is a way of life. Indi Khanna, who will be a planter till the day he himself is planted on some hillside, belongs to this last category; combine this with an amazing zest for life, the irreverence of his Punjabi blood, the memory of a pachyderm, the story telling skills of a born raconteur, and what you get is this exhilarating book. This is not a book that tells you how to grow tea, or the difference between a first flush and a poker flush. What it does tell you, however, in 39 delightful chapters and the frequent four letter word, is about the hard working, hard playing life of a tea planter in India, starting with the "muster" before sun break and ending with that last drink at the planters' club (or in a swamp as the chapter A Slight Mishap honestly reveals!) post midnight.

Tea as a commercial crop was introduced in the Assam valley by the British in the 1830s and had expanded to the Nilgiris in the South by the 1850s. It is today one of India's biggest industries: the country is the world's second largest producer, churning out 1.38 billion kgs every year from 619000 hectares of plantations, valued at US$ 12 billion. But it is more than just an industry or product. Tea is the stuff of legends, it has created an entire sub-culture and way of life, and those who work on its plantations are a breed apart, not unlike the pioneer homesteaders of the American Wild West! The USP of this book is that it introduces us to this genre of homo sapiens as few others do.

Tea planters, of necessity, had to be self sufficient till very recently, in the era before four-lane highways, televisions, cell phones, OLEX or Blinkit, internet, FAX or mobile banking, which is the period the author recounts in this book. They had to be innovative, creative, adventurous, prepared for surprises, and the "jugad" was part of their SOP. The forty odd stories in this book explain this in greater and side-splitting detail. A few need to be mentioned to give the reader a flavour of what Indi Khanna has cooked up!

Nothing Was Ever Im-'piss'-able informs us that an important part of an Asstt. Manager's job was to faithfully record (in a rain measure) every morning the precipitation in the past 24 hours since it had a bearing on productivity and future planning. Indi was perplexed by the fact that, of his 13 fields, one consistently recorded much higher rainfall than the other 12. Looking at it from every angle failed to deliver any reason or answer for this mystery. So he decided to pitch his tent one night next to the rain gauge to witness for himself any unusual phenomenon that could explain this. He was roused from his sleep well past midnight by lusty singing and swearing sounds; he saw the night watchman, thoroughly sozzled, totter and weave his way to the rain gauge and empty his full bladder (with remarkable accuracy) into the said receptacle, and wander off! He apparently did this every night, being a man of regular habits. Indie had solved the mystery, though he does not tell us what exact explanation he gave his boss.

My favourite story in the book has the same thread- or is it 'stream'-of piss running through it. Appropriately titled Pissing Golf, it details how native jugad modified the original game of golf invented in St. Andrews. In the planters' club, one didn't need to be good at golf to win a tournament, one needed to have a strong bladder and do the Kegel's exercise regularly. The rules of the tournament demanded that one have a very large, Patiala size drink (Bloody Mary or beer) before teeing off at each of  6 of the 9 holes (the others being 'dry' holes). No great shakes, you say? But wait for Rule 2: no one was allowed, on pain of penalties, to relieve himself behind a bush or elsewhere till he had holed out at the 9th hole! Try that, Tiger Woods! One presumes that those with prostate problems were not encouraged to take part in the tournament.

The other stories are equally hilarious and give us an honest glimpse of the lives of the planters, whether in Assam or the Nilgiris, places where the author served. They include accosting elephants and wild boars, catching trout in the mountain streams (always ensuring that the fish caught were never bigger than the boss's catch!), floating down the mighty Brahmaputra for days on an improvised "home" built on eight drums lashed together, bringing up kids with the sole assistance of a volume of Benjamin Spock, repaying Divali card debts, not in cash, but in bovine currency, living in a haunted 'chang' house (one on stilts) where the thunder-box was want to collapse if the incumbent didn't watch his weight!

Each story is a delightful gem, related with self deprecating humour- Indi Khanna churns them out, not with his tongue- in- cheek, but with the said appendage firmly stuck out, challenging you to protest or do better. Do not, however, presume that it was all fun and games for the planters and their families. Beneath the fun is the reality of an intrepid breed of men and women, fending for themselves in remote regions without the amenities we take for granted in today's urban communities. It was a hard life- living in isolated locations, cut off from the larger family and friends for eleven months in a year, having to send their children to hostels at the age of five or six, working round the clock 24X7, especially during the plucking and factory processing seasons, finding their own quick-fixes when things went wrong or broke, dealing with undisciplined and sometimes violent labour, a medical officer substituting for a vet and vice versa! But they took all this in their stride, supported by a close circle of friends and colleagues, an undaunted pioneering spirit, and, of course, that vital Planters' Club. In a way, they have created history. This book is a light-hearted record of how this history was made. Which is why it is a must-read for all those who partake of the cup that cheers, but does not inebriate. And don't take that last bit too literally, says Indi Khanna.