It should come as no surprise that, under the influence of our latest soul-mate Israel, Raisina Hill has now become our version of Mount Sinai, from where regular proclamations are issued by the presiding Prophet. The latest- that BJP shall win more than 370 seats and NDA 400+ in the coming Parliamentary elections- is, however, pregnant with connotations and implications. Is this eleventh Commandment a sign of confidence, a well prepared alibi, or a smokescreen for something worse?
I cannot see any legitimate justification for any such confidence. At its present tally of 303 the BJP has plateaued out in the West and its Hindi heartland stronghold: it cannot improve its tally here. It's prospects are no better in the East and South than they were in 2019- in fact, they have deteriorated in Karnataka, Telangana and in the North-east with Congress wins in the first two and the fires in Manipur in the latter. If at all, the BJP is likely LOSE a substantial number of seats: according to the data crunching site run by Ajay Prakash, WHAT DOES THIS DATA SAY, the BJP's total tally is likely to come down by 40 seats, at the very least.
Certain recent developments have not favoured the BJP either. Its insidious efforts came a cropper in Jharkhand where the JMM retained its government, notwithstanding the machinations of the ED and Raj Bhavan. In Bihar Tejaswi Yadav appears to have emerged stronger after Nitish Kumar's defection. In Chandigarh the INDIA alliance has emerged victorious in the Mayoral elections and the PM's party stands fully exposed. The striking down of the Electoral bonds may not amount to much in real terms because the BJP has already pocketed Rupees 6500 crores thanks to the delay by the Supreme Court in deciding the case, but it is a big moral defeat for the government, exposing once again the unconstitutional means it adopts to win elections. That the party is smarting from this judgment is evident from the PM's mocking remarks that today, even if Sudama were to give some rice to Krishna, someone would file a PIL and the court would strike it down! Even the brazen retaliation of blocking the bank accounts of the Congress two days later was struck down by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in short order. Seat sharing among the INDIA alliance partners is not the failure that the bought- out media would have us believe: it is proceeding apace and has been hammered out in U.P, Delhi and Maharashtra, and appears likely in Haryana and Goa. The decision to go their separate ways in Bengal and Punjab makes sense tactically as it will split the anti-incumbency votes. Don't let NDTV and INDIA TODAY convince you otherwise with their slanted coverage and Mood Of The Nation Polls- they reflect more the moods of Msrs Adani and Aroon Purie than that of the common public.
The revived farmers' agitation is bad news for the ruling party too, and will become even worse if violence ensues, as appears likely, given that the government has learnt no lessons from the 2021 agitation. It's reliance on brute force as a panacea for all protests cannot deliver for ever and the people are beginning to recognize it for the tyrannical regime it is. There is widespread sympathy for the farmers this time, except perhaps among the pampered elites of Delhi who do not even know the difference between MSP and MRP, and can't be bothered so long as their Zomato delivery arrives on time.
The government's febrile actions over the last couple of months also do not demonstrate that it is acting from a position of confidence; on the contrary, they display a certain desperation and nervousness. The frantic campaign to engineer defections of all and sundry have degraded the BJP from a washing machine to a garbage bin: it is now collecting all kinds of trash from other parties, people it branded as corrupt repeatedly, including the likes of Ajit Pawar and Ashok Chavan. Very soon, having collected all the rubbish from other parties, it will become a patchwork quilt of opportunists and lose its strong ideological character. According to an analysis carried out by the digital platform, Knocking News, out of 303 MPs in the party only 134 are original BJP types, the rest are all imports from other parties. It is becoming a "Congress yukt" party in rapid order.
The fear of losing is prompting other knee jerk reactions: the constant targeting of Rahul Gandhi's BJY-2 (which was not the case in BJY-1), the resumed personal attacks on him and his family, the renewed attempts at polarised violence in Haldwani, the frantic rush to introduce the Common Civil Codes in BJP ruled states, the raising of the specter of CAA and NRC by the Home Minister again, the reported de-activation of Aadhar cards as alleged by the West Bengal Chief Minister, the wholesale conferment of Bharat Ratnas in order to appropriate the memory of dead legends even as the party spurns all that they stood for. The list goes on, but it indicates one thing, as surely as the Mayoral elections in Chandigarh indicated brazen rigging of votes: that these are not the actions of a party confident of not only a victory, but of a two thirds majority! The BJP may be facing a reality check, finally, and in the process is committing one blunder after another. With each such fiasco it is denting its image even further.
It's election narrative this time sounds decidedly hollow and devoid of any substance; it offers nothing but the three M's- Mandir, Masjid and Muslim, a refrain which is beginning to sound jaded and repetitive. Real economic improvement has bypassed 90% of the country's population and this shows in just about every human development matrix. The so-called Modi's Guarantees are nothing but discredited Jumlas after cosmetic plastic surgery. So, one comes back to the question one posed at the beginning of this piece: What makes the BJP so confident of a landslide victory in spite of all these adverse indications ?
The clues, perhaps, are to be found in the manner in which the ground is being prepared- the constant refrain of 400+ seats, the slanted pre-poll surveys endorsing these estimates, and the amplification of these predictions by an obliging media. So that when the 400+ IS declared after the polling, people would not question it because they had already been pre-conditioned to expect it! Could it be that the BJP has a joker up its sleeve? The EVMs perhaps? A national roll out of the Chandigarh Mayoral model, under the benevolent gaze of the Election Commission?
I really don't know. But I am reminded of that intriguing quote from Arthur Conan Doyle:
"When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."
Think about it. And worry.
# just as the INC had everyone take for granted it was the party of 'we the people' when it was nothing more than that of the entitled class, compradors, trusties, many of whom had for generations done well out of inglistan's romantic imaginary that was the raj; and the 'comrades' would have the working class believe it was their party when it was simply the party of the crafty politburo; similarly national socialists bhajapaa is not the party of hindus but that of the bazaar. when both the INC came to power in the first general election, and the national socialists in the 16th general election, 79 percent of eligible voters failed to endorse the winning party that came to power. jawaharlal nehru and narendra modi formed their governments based on nothing more than the pareto ratio, viz. 20 percent of any gathering are zealous supporters, while 20 percent are vehemently against, and 60 percent are generally disinterested. 20 percent of the fervent will turn up to vote bhajaapa, and of the 60 percent undecided if the national socialists succeed in winning over 10 percent they should coast to victory. the bazaar, the chambers of commerce are made up those with a healthy appetite for risk, there is no reason that it will not triumph.
ReplyDeletesir, ur analasis is very good, i want to know full details of ajay prakash data regarding 2024 elections, i face difficulty to find him on internet, can u please share the data link, my email id: gamdisri@gmail.com, iam a telugu journalist
ReplyDeleteMost of the Institutions have been compromised and majority of bureaucrats in cow belt have been turned into obedient lambs under this present condition everything is in favour of NDA. The role of EC will be far from neutral. Also the religiosity fervour amongst the majority religion is at peak after Ram Mandir event & Modi has turned into Avtar in Hindi Heart Belt. My reading of the situation.
ReplyDeleteFervently hope you are right. Otherwise we will become a democracy like N Korea
ReplyDeletePerhaps the Diaspora is the joker or ace up the sleeve? Well supported by money-ed middle class overwhelmed by a cheering hysteria in a Dubai stadium, that misses all in its cacophony and therefore the abusive role at home :
ReplyDelete- the discontent within itself - cringing ministers and lying sycophantic spinners and collaborators; the arrogance of one and just the lotus ( interrupted? great turn of phrase by the way!) - with no one else on show.
- the new connect between the poorest, the disenfranchised and the unemployed-disillusioned, finding voice for once on national air;
- the ordinariest of ordinaries speaking in contempt of the neglect inflicted over the last 10 years;
- the chasm between impression and reality in terms of truths - in economy; legislation, execution, persecution and intimidation;
- the arrogance of one and just the lotus ( interrupted? Great turn of phrase by the way!) - with no one else on show.
- "Flickers of Hope" is what the seat stats say - an analysis piece widely in circulation right now.
- And at long last, open defiance. Gauntlets thrown. Not one but more and more.
Time will tell if "We the people" have what it really takes to make the change to save this nation. The past is showing up the way, for better and worse. And suddenly the voice for change is audible: give us back who we are. Not for the world but for ourselves.
We are hurtling towards a single party 'democracy'. Why? Complete desimation of corrupt, venal & ideology mukt opposition. Which idiot goes on a yatra just before such a defining LS election? Religious fervour at a high post Ram Mandir consecration. BJP as you rightly said is flush with funds & crony capitalism is rampant otherwise captains of industry will be locked up.
ReplyDeleteThe Lotus, if interrupted at all, will be done so by extraneous forces certainly other than the Opposition.
ReplyDeleteThe Judiciary is one resistor and has thankfully indicated it is alive still. Yet it only declared the bonds unconstitutional; it did not stop the usage of the accumulated pelf.
The farmers are perhaps the prime movers that could obstruct the Lotus in its current dash for the end line. They appear to be the only barrier - physical and spectral - to instill some notion of a setback into this arrogant juggernaut.
The ongoing ethnic violence in Manipur is a powder keg that holds the potential to singe the Lotus.
The Election Commission needs to locate its spine. If it does, it will perhaps disallow Modi’s bearded face to smile benevolently on every ration bag distributed free.
To hope for the Media - that fourth pillar of democracy - to participate equitably in this ongoing process will be a ludicrous premise. It functions with Modi’s imprimatur and exists solely for the Lotus.
Finally, the deciders of their fortunes need to analyse if the route to their Amritkaal is the correct one as they tread the slopes of religious uniformism and communal majoritarianism.
But this is where the quandary sets in. What is the alternative presented to those who do not wish to step upon the proverbial Road to Perdition? An insipid, languid, directionless Opposition that is squabbling internally despite the election barely five weeks away!
Is this amalgam worthy of those extraneous resistances referred to earlier, to interrupt the Lotus from blooming a third term? Avay Shukla has hitherto been the unhinging optimist, inspired like those hardy souls during the Gold Rush to locate a nugget or two from endless sifting. This time though, one does not detect any such hunt in his musings, but a prayer from weary resignation at the end of a strenuous and fruitless search. Contrastingly, Brother George appears ruthless in his scrutiny as he discombobulates the grand old party. Let us await the outcome.
Interesting information
ReplyDeleteI don’t care a fig when friends call me an idiot for being the eternal optimist, but as I see it now, I see more than just a glimmer of light, what I call the darkest hour before the brightest dawn.
ReplyDeleteIts the old adage that while you can fool some people all the time, but definitely can’t fool all the people all the time.
Oh yes! I see hope aplenty.
Am, however, very conscious of that one joker in the pack – that damn EVM!!!
The Farmer agitation has been shown as it is - fraud. The way these Punjab elements waged war on Haryana can not be justified in any manner. The agitation is finished.
ReplyDeleteThe PM and BJP are confident because of their delivery on the ground. There is no need to list their development achievement,
Manipur is one of the seven sisters. Rest of the NE doesn't care about its situation. Assam itself has hundreds of tribes and can't worry about kuki and Maeti. Assam is firmly on road of development and checking encroachment by Bangladeshi muslims. How can and Indian be sympathetic to AIUDF and AIMIM just for hate of BJP and RSS or anyone who replaced the GOP.
Karnataka must be already fed up with Siddu and his antics. South India will give more seats to BJP. If not seats, the vote share is definitely going to increase giving hope for next time.
Not a word on Sandeshkhali by INDI and its supporters. Sandeshkhali may become Singur for TMC.
How can intelligent people forget Jungle Raj and support son of convicted criminal himself in dock for land from poor for jobs!!!
Having seen Yogi in action in UP i can confidently say Yogi has finished Akhilesh and MAya for good. as such what do they offer?
The opposition has to work hard rather than damaging country with caste, north-south divide and these fraud farmer/CAA andolans or emptying state coffers with freebies. Rahul is biggest assett for BJP with his family. I suspect thats why they dont put the family in jail and out of politics otherwise Congress may still revive.
EVM is there for anyone to prove compromised. Dont worry, wherever opposition works hard or are able to fool people, EVM favours them
Just wondering that when you dunk your head into it, don't specks of cow dung get into your eyes?
DeleteThank you for your enlightened response
DeleteWith the Broadcast bill, the little information of what's going on in the country, which we get through social.media channels seems to be coming to an end. With our amazing "news" channels spewing hatred and one sided stories, reminds us of the news on North Korean TVs.
ReplyDelete"the joker up its sleeve" is none other than the Modi itself.
ReplyDeleteI am reminded of "fair is foul and foul is fair" alternatively.
Andhbhakts..Eyes wide shut
ReplyDelete