Add this

Saturday 19 March 2022

NEW FILES, SAME OLD GUILES.

   When was the last time you heard our revered Prime Minister recommend a film to his MPs and colleagues ? In fact, I am a bit astonished that he even has the time to see a movie in his packed 18 hours working day, but obviously he made the time to view The Kashmir Files ( even if he missed Rana Ayub's The Gujarat Files: this last bit is an assumption, of course, since he has not made any similar recommendation for it).

  So what's so special about TKF, apart from the fact that its Director, stars and financiers are known BJP acolytes? We can leave the merits of the film, its historical fidelity, intentions and box office collections to be debated by the Whats App university ( where, I learn, they are soon going to offer a quick course on "Pundits and Whodunits ?" ) My own view is that the importance of TKF is that it provides the missing link between the 2022 state elections and the 2024 general elections. Let me explain.

  The Kashmir Files has provided the BJP a much needed opportunity to upgrade its Hindutva model. The just concluded UP hustings have demonstrated that the old model- based on Aurangzeb, hijab, beef, conversions, love jihad, Mandirs- has become jaded, over-used, and did not produce the same torque and horse power as earlier. A new hybrid engine was needed to produce the RPMs and charge up the faithfuls. If Mahindra could do it with the Thar, why not the country's biggest assembly line of the external combustion engine? TKF does this very well- half fact, half innuendo, history blended with historicide, liberals with leftists and the JNU types. At the centre of this narration, of course, is the archetypal villain, the slouching beasts numbering 200 million who pose the greatest danger to our civilisation and culture. Which is why this film is now the new vehicle which will replace the Ram Rath and the Yogi's bulldozer and drive the BJP to power in 2024.

  This is clearly evident not only from the PM's gushing praise for the film, but also from the rising crescendo of tweets and WA forwards, the social media pressure on Bollywood notables to do likewise and to jump onto the bhaktwagon. And it certainly cannot be a happy coincidence that as many as 7 BJP state govts( at last count) have exempted the movie from Entertainment tax. Mr Vivek Agnihotri has even received the ultimate accolade- Kangana Runout has announced that she is willing to work with him! Even the Oscar would pale in comparison with this encomium.

  A deliberate, calculated, nation-wide hysteria is being built up to reinforce the " Hinduism is in danger" trope, to underline the  "UP will become like Kashmir and Bengal" threat. Parliament and state Assemblies are arranging free screenings of the movie for its overworked members, business houses are giving discounts to those who have seen it, in Kanpur ( I was there this week) RWAs are offering free tickets to its residents ( no prizes for guessing where the money for this is coming from). Voices which plead for restraint and sanity are mercilessly trolled. The intention clearly is to exhume the ghosts of 30 years ago, re-open wounds which were healing, to keep alive, not the patient, but the maggots of hate and fear.

  It is certainly not my intention to decry or belittle the unspeakable sufferings of the Kashmiri pundits. What happened to them should not happen in any country, far less in a nation with a rich legacy of pluralism and tolerance. My objection is to the insane tumult and furore being manufactured to paint all Muslims with the Kashmiri terrorist brush, the selective brutalisation of a community. Let us not forget that the oppression of the Kashmiri pundits is not unique, it is just one such incident in our sometimes blood soaked history: there were others- the 1984 killing of Sikhs in even larger numbers than the pundits, the Nellie massacre in Assam, the Chattisinghpora killings in Kashmir, the NE Delhi riots of 2020, the Muzzafarnagar riots of 2013. And of course, the Gujarat carnage of 2002. Indeed, it is ironical that our Prime Minister, praising TKF, castigates those who " do not want the truth ( about Kashmiri pundits) to be told." I say so because how many of us even remember a film called PARZANIA , made in 2007? It was about the massacre of residents ( mainly Muslims, of course) of the Gulbarg Housing Society in the 2002 Gujarat riots. This film was not allowed to be screened in Gujarat and, to the best of my knowledge, that position prevails till today. More than one can hide the truth. Maybe the Gujarat Assembly will screen it for its members, now that the age of Truth has dawned?

  What needs to be unequivocally condemned, therefore, is the selective double standards, the exploitation of the Kashmiri pundits for political purposes, the heartless use of their genuine sufferings to demonise one community, to fan the embers which were dying out in the merciful womb of history. And what is even more unacceptable to me is that this cynical propaganda is being engineered by a party under whose joint watch in Delhi this exodus happened, a party whose eminent leader was the Governor of the state of Kashmir at the time and exercised absolute powers, This same political party has subsequently ruled that state in partnership with a Kashmiri party it now holds partly responsible for the incidents. And the same political party has since been in power at the center for more than 12 years. Time enough, one would think, for it to have ensured the safe return of the Kashmiri pundits to Kashmir, to enable the restoration of their lost properties, to compensate them for their losses, to bring to book the perpetrators of the violence. But it has not moved one inch on these matters.

  And then, of course, I would much rather this government and party talked, and showed the same concern and outrage, about some of the other files in the nation's sealed cupboards: the Rafale files, for instance, or the Panama and Pandora files, the Pegasus files, the Electoral Bonds files, the Judge Loya files, the Gogoi files ( which probably need a separate cupboard by themselves). I'm not a great movie buff but I would love to watch movies on these files and would hope that they too are given tax breaks. In fact, I foresee happy days for all those Netflix addicts: one producer has already announced that he will make a film titled the GUJARAT FILES, Akhilesh Yadav has expressed the hope that someone would produce the LAKHIMPUR FILES. Ashok Khemka ( he of the repeated transfers fame) could launch his political career with a film called THE ESCAPEGOAT FILES. It's showtime, folks, so get ready for your next lesson in history ! 

15 comments:

  1. The film industry was perhaps the last bastion that had stayed unsullied by communal partisanship till 2014. It is also crumbling before the majoritarian forces as we see each day. Doyens like Amitabh Bachchan, superstars like Akshay Kumar, exemplars like Anupam Kher, talents like Vivek Agnihotri and imbeciles like Kangana - all exhibit the unmistakable tilt towards majoritarianism, nationalism and communalism in varying shades of support. Their resisting counterparts within the industry are trolled relentlessly, and have the institutional canines of the regime set upon them to bring them to financial and social exhaustion.
    That the Prime Minister should personally recommend a movie based upon a narrative and vouch for its portrayal of the "truth", while ensuring another movie made earlier stayed banned in his home state because it supposedly depicted the same narrative, but unmasked a truth uncomfortable to him, speaks volumes of the charade being played out.
    The endgame of this regime is to "cleanse" the nation of the "major" minority. This must be averted because it takes the country on a spiral trajectory of doom from which there is no hope of return or recovery. No amount of filmmaking will then save the land from an inevitable debacle.
    The analogy to the automobile industry, as also the wordplay of the "external combustion engine" is gut-cramping fabulous….! Though the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM), I suspect, may be aggrieved at having an elevated member's posterior whipped for no perceivable fault of his….! But then Avay Shukla and his hebdomadal lashings know no reduction, do they?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We are indeed 'doomed'if we sit tight mutely.
      Every single case/ matter/ issue brought to the Supreme Court and its magical decrees, notices and quiet sweeps (of 'now you see it and now you don't') has to be brought to bear on truth and the criminality of persuasive suppression.
      That may well be "mehnat" for now. Till the next stage.

      Delete
  2. It says 'No comments' above. In large font, as if the blog mechanics back stage was making, by dint of its punctuation, a grim observation, even as it dared a response.
    But after the deluge there are words again. Strong enough to suggest more than a clearing of throat.
    As far as an important section of influential media is concerned, the Congress party plus BSP and others must squarely be blamed and held responsible for the Great Victory.
    That a majority of people when actually voting, in the booth, give resignedly in to the lack of choice. What a young Uber driver referred to as 'chehara'.
    Perhaps.
    But the young man did not simply mean popularity. He also said, ‘Mehnat karna par ta hai. Sabka baska nahi hai.’
    And therefore does this imply, on the one hand that, there is a large gap between common folk and their perceptions as to what (and who) they would actually like to vote for in order for the quality of life to change and what we are seeing, by default, on the ground?
    It's time to get the fundamentals right. For each of what is mentioned above. With 'mehnat'.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The British raped, killed, stole and pillaged our country but we, with our slavish mentality, look adoringly at the the whites who can do no wrong. But our own country men, who have lived in this land for centuries are now the nominated villians. I don't understand us.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well brought out by Abay .For how long the facts would be covered and pushed under the carpet.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Once again our Hukmaran are back to their games of 'Come what may, hum kursi nahin chhorenge' and the polity be damned. Bad and sad times, especially when our potential enemies are sharpening their swords, while we are wasting our time in internal and meaningless squabbles.

    Well written Avay.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The author has missed The Sanjiv Bhatt Files.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The high level endorsement of TKF that was faithfully carried by the effusively 'more loyal than the king' media channels actually subverted the poignant narrative of the film! The media carnage that has followed bears testimony to the fact that there is a dangerous herd mentality that will blindly follow wherever manipulation takes them... Is the argumentative Indian a fiction? Or is this furore also just the current flavour of the season until another divisive issue is fuelled? My heart goes out to kashmiri pundits and it appears that a well made film has been made a convenient hand maiden of the time tested 'divide and rule' formula! Brutality has no religion or nation and any selective High level endorsement should come with the caveat that 'those who live in glass houses should not throw stones'!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Now I have developed immunity to hate politics and there is no end to it soon. The noise will only get louder with each passing day. So I have put on my ear plugs and avoid the din. But I feel sorry for my childhood muslim friends who have been literally reduced to second class citizens in their own country. I always admire the witty style of writing of Avay.

    ReplyDelete
  9. THIS trash is what this lovely country has been and IS being further reduced to.
    Hide inconvenient truths and market and drum up hate so that the few threads which hold us together may not just get frayed, but separate.
    Is this what a government is supposed to do? One that thumps its 56" chest with a 'sabka saath sabka vikas' unadulterated bullshit.
    This is not the country we were all born into. This is Germany -1985!!!
    And this TKF piece of garbage needs to be consigned back to the sewage pit it has reared up its filthy head from

    ReplyDelete
  10. Let us keep aside TKF and ask the 56" Chest and Six Packs guy that for all muscle flexing on 5th August 2019 and removal of article 370, have the objective of making JK peaceful happened. Has KPs return to Kashmir been felicitated.How many new Industries have reached JK. Have terrorists joined the mainstream.
    There is no representative Government. English Newspapers have been crippled by stopping all State advertisements. This is verily against DAVP proclaimed rules.

    ReplyDelete
  11. It angers and saddens me to see the depleting state of our nation...our thought process is being navigated towards complete zombie like state where...issues like...progress...environment..jobs.. education...tourism...industrialization..sports..fun...togetherness....etc...etc...etc...have ceased to exist...and we've started enjoying thriving on blood...anger...savgery...hatred...mistrust..arguments...the list is endless...
    But i believe in miracles...!!! We will be rid of this thrash and live in harmony without the radicles...we just need to hang in together for a long long time...
    Avay...thanks for being our voice !!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And therein lies the rub; as long as constituents choose to express their thougbts througb a proxy, the hounds will set upon the proxy. Speak individually and just maybe the numbers shall blunt or break the fangs on the hounds...

      Delete
    2. While currently, collectively, the country is up shit-creek without a paddle and from recent alarming developments appears to be going further down the drain, as long as folk such as ourselves are hanging in there, there is hope.
      Every night HAS to end in a sunrise. It's just the way of life.

      Delete
  12. We must not forget our past because it gives inspiration to progress in future.Let India achieve its glory in future.

    ReplyDelete