Freedom of speech is a wonderful thing, for without it we would never know who the idiots among us are. Like the celebrity anchor on an English news channel who on the 26th evening equated the tractor parade in Delhi to the insurrection on Capitol Hill on the 6th of this month! Or those other lamebrains who don't know the difference between the Nishan Sahib and the Khalistan flag. Had it not been for our fundamental right to speak our minds we would never have known of these delayed- fuse time bombs planted in the nation's public discourse.
As you sow, so shall you reap: the farmer has known this for a long time but Mr. Modi and his government are learning this only now. If we go beyond the scattered violence in Delhi on Republic Day ( which was not more than what was heaped on the students of JNU and Jamia Millia last year by a police force " exercising maximum restraint") the overwhelming turn-out of farmers/ villagers from many states indicates that this movement is no longer about the three farm bills alone. It is just as much about the betrayal, calumny, humiliation, vilification and persecution they have endured at the hands of the govt. and its media collaborators for the last few months. Our rural communities may not have much money in their current accounts but they have something far more valuable which a callous Delhi has tried to rob them off: pride and dignity. The protests are also about this.
It is just as much about the slow and lingering decline of rural India and its hardy communities, the falling share of agriculture in the GDP, the non-delivery of basic services which we in Delhi, Mumbai and Chennai take for granted. Notwithstanding our Constitution, there are many categories of citizens in the nation and the farmer occupies perhaps the bottom slot. He is not considered worthy of being allowed into Delhi's Lutyen's zone, not even onto the outer Ring Road, and to keep him out we have resorted to the medieval tactics of digging trenches and moats, erecting barriers and firing (water) cannons. We live in two Indias: urban India which benefitted from the post 1991 neo-liberal reforms and produced 102 billionaires ( 2020 figures, fourth highest in the world) and 330,000 High Net Worth Individuals; and the second, rural Bharat where 200 million go hungry every night and 40% of whose children suffer from malnutrition. Nothing encapsulated this dichotomy better than, ironically, the split screens of TV channels on Republic Day: on the left were grand scenes of the embellished militaristic march past on Rajpath viewed by well clad politicians and officials, on the right the sight of unadorned farmers driving into Delhi's outskirts on tractors.
Rural India has been abandoned on our journey to the fabled five trillion dollar economy. Consider some of the statistics. The urban per capita income( Net Value Added) in 2018-19 was Rs. 98435.00 while the figure for rural areas was Rs. 40924.00, less than half. This is inevitable when one factors in the fact that whereas agriculture provides only 15% of GDP, it accounts for 40% of total employment.
In 2011-12, according to the Consumer Expenditure Survey of GOI, the average monthly household expenditure in urban areas was Rs. 2630.00: the corresponding rural figure was Rs. 1430.00. ( The survey figures for 2017-18 are available but have not been released by the govt., presumably because it does not suit it.)
Agriculture, which is the mainstay of our villages, is becoming increasingly unviable and farmers are exiting it in hordes. The NSO data shows that the rate of exit from farming is 2.04% per annum. To appreciate the magnitude of this tragedy, absorb this: 34 million farmers moved out of agriculture between 2004-05 and 2011-12. They now wander between our prospering cities as migrant labour. Which is why, for the first time in decades, in December 2020 rural unemployment at 9.15% was higher than urban unemployment rates ( CMIE report). Commensurate with this is the shockingly high suicide rate among the farming community, far higher than the national average: more than 300,000 farmers have killed themselves in the last 25 years- a little more than 10000 every year.
About 50 million people have been displaced ( " development refugees") since Independence, and their exodus continues at the rate of 500,000 per annum. Their lands are appropriated at ridiculous prices for projects which actually help urban India only- dams, mines, highways, SEZs, urbanisation, airports. The tribals are the worst affected, with many states yet to implement the Forests Rights Act. If these oustees are lucky they get jobs as unskilled labour on the lands they were once self-sufficient owners of, if unlucky they will migrate to some fetid urban slum.
Rural India is being denuded of its resources- land, water, forests, minerals, labour- in a massive transfer of resources from the rural poor to the rich corporates. The three farm laws will transfer the last remaining asset- agricultural crops- also to these favoured entities. The pandemic itself provides proof of this: while 120 million people, mainly migrant labour from the villages, lost their jobs in the last one year, the top 100 billionaires INCREASED their wealth by 35% or 400 billion dollars in the same period, according to a recent OXFAM report.
There is , relatively speaking, little development of our villages while tens of thousands of crores are spent on cities- flyovers, metros, river-front beautification, Central vistas, stadiums, even statues of the dead to pander to the egos of the living. The govt. plans to spend Rs. 200,000 crores on 5151 Smart City projects- what about the 600,000 villages where almost half our population resides? Even basic services and facilities are not available in them: to take just one example, 80% of doctors and hospital beds are in cities, the villages are expected to manage with " hybridpathic" doctors- a mix of allopathy and ayurveda.
Rural India is crying out for some attention, not more exploitation and neglect. The farm laws are the final assault and the final frontier. The farmers know it and it is time for our pampered upper middle classes, the backbone of the present government, to wake up to this. The current protests have many layers and it is time to stop oversimplifying them in the language of arrogance, privilege and contempt. Dignity and a proud self respect is just about the only thing we have left our farmers with, and the urbanised sophisticate is now attempting to denude them of that too. The Golf Links socialite who is aghast at the so-called " desecration" of the national flag at the Red fort should know that the Punjab and Haryana farmer has seen his sons draped in the tiranga when their bodies are brought from our borders, he doesn't need to be lectured about the flag by a gin drinking neo-colonial.
The farmer IS India and his roots are too old to be dug up by megalomaniacs, opportunists, sycophants and the elite. He will eventually claim what is rightfully his. Bharat had come to India on Republic Day and has left its visiting card. India is now on test. As the poet said:
Manzil to mil he jayegi, bhatak kar hi sahi;
Gumrah toh woh hain jo ghar se nikle hi nahin.
Straight from the heart yet rationally argued with facts and figures. One thought rural India had only vanished from the Hindi cinema it has vanished from our hearts and minds as well. The selfish middle class cannot see beyond their nose they are moved only when their interests are hurt one almost whishes....
ReplyDeleteI do not know how much of Bharat will eventually become India, but it is certain that the hordes of underemployed and displaced villagers will have to find their manzils within hopeless and squalid peri-urban slums, which is neither here nor there. It is this future that is being hastened by policies that will destroy the agriculture and the countryside as we have known and understood it for Millenia.
ReplyDeleteBharat is on move to become stronger india . It's beginning to be a wonderful achievement
DeleteVery well written article and every word is 100% truth.
DeleteBrilliant as always Avey
ReplyDeleteI see increasing doom and gloom.Lets not forget the bond between Kisan and Jawan!
ReplyDeleteWonderfully put. Even though it could well mean the early disruption of much of our comfortable lives, it is vital the farmers succeed in forcing a far greater allocation of resources for themselves. They deserve a fair return for their skills and hard labour.
ReplyDeleteVery much true ������
ReplyDeleteLet justice rolls in India
Super ❤️
ReplyDeleteInsightful and now we need to brain storm how to make this better.
ReplyDeleteAn eye opener from all angles and hope people in right places take note of. At the same time one wonders as to what has been his contribution towards rural development/ setting priorities right. Hope he comes out with more revealing facts regularly.
ReplyDeleteanother clarion call to see the writing on the wall..especially the ostriches sitting in comfortable enclaves forming vacuous opinions on these farmers without realising that heat will soon get to them too....not in threats that are stirred as perceptions into their martinis but in a more insiduous erosion of the Constitution of India and its guardian...for a minute even if we put aside merit based arguments on the farm laws..we as citizens certainly need answers to the following two fundamental constitutional breaches in these contentious laws:- 1) how are States debarred in these laws from making any laws on agriculture which is a State subject as per the constituiton? 2) how is the fundamental right to judicial remedies denied when these farm laws provide no recourse to Courts for legal redressal-- only ans SDM can be approached ? If these glaring aberrations of the constituion have been overlooked by the guardian of the Constituion for reasons best known to them then is this breach not the harbinger of a dangerous trend with the farm laws being a test run???
ReplyDeleteIf States have the wherewithal to give the MSP on their own within their own State, it should be no problem. I don't think that is the case. Some States want MSP to stay, but it should be paid by the Centre. Consequently the Centre and State subject argument becomes weak
DeleteImprovements in urban settings are created from taxes paid by the urban tax payers. Rural India, including the rich, do not pay any taxes. Start taxing them with the proviso thst all taxes from rural India will be utilised only in rural areas, state wise.
ReplyDeleteA very comprehensive in depth look in soul of India.A immediate action for uplift of rural India(Soul) is the requirement, it is because of them we got Independence.
ReplyDeleteYou are dead wrong, Mr. Ramaswami, when you say that farmers don't pay taxes. In the first place, farmers pay ALL the Indirect taxes and cesses that you and I pay, and at the same rates. As regards Income Tax ( which does not apply to agricultural income), may I remind you that the average income of a farming household in India is just a little more than Rs. 4000.00 per month ( NSO data). That puts him below the tax threshold. 80% of them have small and marginal holdings and practice sustenance farming only. Urban Indians with far higher incomes do not pay Income Tax after they have obtained the benefit of various exemptions. So please do not spread this canard to justify the gross inequity which farmers are subjected to.
ReplyDeleteThat said, I am all for taxing the rich farmers, but that will never happen. Not because the govt has any love for the farming community but because " agricultural income" is the standard conduit for laundering illicit gains/ wealth of politicians and corrupt bureaucrats.
View from the other side
ReplyDelete*It is not farm laws but stupid PAN number who is to be blamed for all that is happening.*
Now that it is amply clear that neither so called farmers nor the supporters of agitators here are likely to answer my very basic and simple question, let me elaborate the real reason why so called farmers want the laws withdrawn.
The answer is very simple but nobody will ever mention it because large scale corruption by them is the main reason.
*Now the farm laws state that the farmers income of selling their produce will remain tax free as hitherto.*
No problem till here. Now came the catch and the main reason of the agitation.
*The farm law also requires that the farmer has to indicate the PAN number of the trader whom he sells his produce.*
*Now the trader is not a farmer and is not exempt from Income Tax. So if he buys thousands of crores of fake produce from farmer he has to sell and pay GST as well as income tax on earnings.*
*But in reality neither the farmer has sold anything nor has he bought anything. Till now all farmer ( read sharks) used to show all their I'll gotten wealth as farm income and avail income tax exemption. Now that route has been closed.*
And this is the main reason of the agitation.
*Remember Mr PC in 2012 availed hundreds of crores of IT exemption for selling cauliflower grown in his kitchen garden on grounds as being a farmer.*
*So it is not farm laws but stupid PAN number who is to be blamed for all that is happening.*
You say 34 mollion farmers went out of agriculture between 2004 and 2012. Blaming Congress?
ReplyDeleteBrilliant.. is the word! We need to wake up and earliest!
ReplyDeleteLike the farmer , the soldier , most of our civil service members have done their best for the Country.
ReplyDelete