The last seven days have been a bit of a mixed week for me, somewhat like what the Delhi voter got in 2020 when he voted for Kejriwal : neither fish nor fowl but a chameleon. And for once this dog's breakfast has nothing to do with our presiding trinity- the alliterative ascetic, the corpulent chronologist or the malevolent monk. They have, of course, been up to their devious tricks as heretofore but we shall set them aside for the nonce in order to retain some semblance of our sanity ( a rare commodity in this New India, you will agree).
This particular hebdomad began with a news item sent by a friend who has an eye for the curious ( the other one is for unaccompanied ladies ). If you thought that the only problem with Indians is that they have been growing progressively more stupid since 2014, think again. According to research carried out by JNU and published in PLoS One, analysis of NFHS ( II to IV )data reveals that Indians have been growing shorter since 2012- the average height of the Indian male has declined by 0.86- 1.10 cms and of the female by 0.12 cms ! This is not only curious but also alarming, because average global heights have been increasing. Experts opine that this is due to malnourishment, which is further borne out by the fact that we have now slipped to 101st place out of 116 countries in the Global Hunger Index, below Pakistan, Bangladesh and Nepal. I guess this was inevitable since everyone these days has to subsist on a staple diet of bigotism, minority bashing and lies, which is not known to promote the growth of either body or brain tissue. It may also be due to " too much democracy" and no doubt the Niti Ayog will soon look into the matter, just as soon as it has sold Rashtrapati Bhavan to the highest bidder. The building has a Double A rating and it is only proper that it goes to the " double engine" A+A duo who are driving India's growth. After all, growth of billionaires is far more desirable than the growth of your average Joe's height, isn't it?
But as usual I have a different take on this. Per me, Indians are losing height because Mr. Modi is cutting everyone down to size, along with the economy and the GDP. Come to think of it, have you seen any Opposition leader who is more than 5' 8" in height ? The newer ones, the post- Modi breed- Kanhaiya Kumar, Mahua Moitra, Tejeshwi, Jagan Mohan Reddy, Aditya Thackeray- are even shorter. Of course, Mr. Modi is not exactly a bean pole, but then he makes up for it with a 56" chest and a beard of indeterminate length which waxes and wanes with the moon and his electoral prospects. Perhaps what we are witnessing under this government is a form of reverse-evolution: Indians regressing back to the Neanderthal Man era ( whose average height was below 5'). Neanderthalensis too was a man of few words and all disputes were settled with the liberal use of a club. Seems familiar ? Form and substance appear to be finally coming together, in final confirmation of the promised " Acche Din !"
And now for the good news. How often have you torn your hair out trying to decipher whether your doctor has prescribed Allegra or Viagra for your drooping spirits , or whether he wants you to go to a cinema or have an anema to get rid of that tense feeling ? Doctors seem to derive a sadistic pleasure from writing prescriptions which nobody except a pharmacist can read, and sometimes even he cannot. I do suspect that this is deliberate, because when they write out their consultation bill every zero in it is clearly legible. Things have become so bad that I never trust a prescription where the doctor's signature is legible. My brother, who is a senior consultant and surgeon in Mumbai, confesses that he cannot read his own prescriptions! He has now delegated the task of inscribing them to his secretary who doesn't know the difference between a laxative and a relaxative; by the time the patients find out it's usually too late.
Well, folks, all that's about to change: a High Court has fined three doctors Rs. 5000/ each for writing illegible prescriptions and reports. It was a medico-legal case and the doctors' bad handwriting was held to be an obstruction of justice since even the court could not figure out what they had written! Just imagine if a post mortem report reads " death caused by a sharp wife" when what is intended to be stated is " death caused by a sharp knife " ? Indeed, the court has rendered yeoman's service to future generations. Neerja says she can now sleep easy, knowing that what I suffer from is dyspepsia and not dementia. Though I'll probably get the latter by 2024, but that won't really matter because by then this regime would have lobotomised us all into a nation of halfwits anyway. Blessed are the demented for they will never know what hit them.
https://www.indiatoday.in/india/north/story/indian-kids-today-are-taller-and-heavier-than-earlier-aiims-96597-2012-03-21
ReplyDeleteIndians are growing taller because of better nutrition.
Mr Sahu, your reference/ link is hopelessly outdated. It pertains to 2012 whereas the latest data is based on NFHS ( National Family Health Survey) rounds II to IV covering the period 2012 to 2020. This is the govt's own data. It is further borne out by other findings- that almost 40% of children between 1and 5 years of age are stunted, wasted or underweight. And of course the latest Global Hunger rankings.I'm afraid no amount of blind loyalty to the current regime can hide the cold facts.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThe earlier survey report is dubious. The people covered by the earlier AIIMS study have not disappeared. This report is not “outdated”. There is a conflict between the reports we have cited. This needs to be resolved by further study.
DeleteIn 2020, India was ranked 94th out of 107 countries. Now with 116 countries in the fray, it has dropped to 101st rank. India's GHI score has also decelerated - from 38.8 in 2000 to the range of 28.8 - 27.5 between 2012 and 2021.
GHI scores are calculated on four parameters — undernourishment, child wasting (percentage of children below five years of age who have low weight for their height, reflecting acute under-nutrition), child stunting (percentage of children below five years of age who have low height for their age, reflecting chronic under-nutrition) and child mortality (the mortality rate of children under the age of five).
It is not clear how the performance of India on these indicators has such drastic change from one year to another. Surely, in the pandemic year, actual weighing and measuring would not have been possible. GHI itself declares that it keeps on revising its scoring method and it is not the scores and indicators cannot be compared with the previous reports.
Hilarious. Sir, despite getting the good truth out relentlessly and recklessly, you grow taller in our view, each and every week!!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely! Blessed indeed are the demented.
DeleteDisputing the methodology and disowning the global hunger ranking will not help the cause of India
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed reading every word loaded with Wit n humor. (Even though as a citizen there isnt much to feel enthused about the dismal state of our democracy but you bring forth the mockery going on in the society .the promise of ACHCHE DIN is big joke ...very true reflection our times..era of Post truth .
ReplyDeleteMr. Shukla Courtesy of a good friend I am reading you and writing this note in Paris, France. I cannot say I enjoy reading you - I have loved India since my first reading about her in 1944 and you describe much that causes me pain - yet the very fact that you are writing, and to a large readership, gives me hope. Things are bad an probably will get worse for a time - but this too shall pass.
ReplyDeleteAnd please continue. Chateaubriand wrote (my translation) "When in the silence of abjection the only noises heard are the chains of the slave and the voice of the informer (...) the historian appears, in charge of the peoples' vengeance".
Outstanding line that, and your translation is worthy of finding place anywhere in the libraries of English. Please reveal your name.
Delete"When in the silence of abjection the only noises heard are the chains of the slave and the voice of the informer (...) the historian appears, in charge of the peoples' vengeance".
ReplyDeleteBrilliant. Sheer brilliance.
[Author of above post unnamed].
There has been no name calling. It's all very civil here, thank goodness. The brief indices quoted are from the TOI. We are still at something like 30 infant deaths per thousand. And of these almost 60% are newborn babies. The implication is undernourished mothers and generations of deprivation affecting both parents.
ReplyDeleteNon-political governance has achieved much for this country. But it needs uncompromising leadership at every level. We cannot continue to put alleviation of poverty and better health care on the same job card as everything else. It has to be tackled separately and on a war-footing. This matter has disfigured the country. If we can't see that we need to step aside and make place for competence, dedication and commitment. Nothing else will do.
Nasty is your middle name!!
ReplyDeleteMay your pen never run out of vinegar.
Great stuff.
Avay.. Your tongue-in-cheek comments are simply delicious. View from Greater Kailash seems to have become very salubrious ever since you have gone there.
ReplyDeleteAvay Shukla probably knows more Shuklas in Greenland than I know Patankars in Dadar, Mumbai. One just has to read his blogs to gauge the spread of his ilk, who he makes liberal use of to draw out our tears of mirth, or admire with glazed eyes their achievements. This time the Guns of Shukla were drawn on the poor consultung doctor brother of his, who was stretched, diced, and quartered before us to get us laughing like banshees...I pity him!
ReplyDeleteGood to have a light blog after a couple weighty ones - thank you Sir!
On to the weighty issue now that Avay Shukla touched upon. I am not referring to the corpulent chronologist who seeks a timeline to throw those violating it into the oceans that kiss our coastline. I am referring to the underweighted, wasted, stunted children that we produce day after day and are unable to feed as per the GHI data. If the same is studied before rejecting within 24 hours of its publication, perhaps we will derive inferences on population and diet that may be relevant to the demography going ahead. It is a dichotomy that this regime intends to make the country a 5 trillion economy, yet remain low in the hunger index.
ReplyDeleteThankfully my teenaged son has reached my height, but that is because he is not among the unfortunates who make up the GHI. Not that my height makes sweet limes appear as lemons because of sheer verticality, but he has not followed in the shortening statistic of Indian men that Avay Shukla has cited!
Brilliant as ever. You echo my thought processes and how. God bless. Stay heathy
ReplyDeleteRita Menon
ReplyDeleteHilarious as always however, clarification on "sharp wife" robbed the wit a bit. Happy writing.
ReplyDeleteNow I understand, why the Pen is mightier than the sword.
ReplyDelete