Saturday, 14 March 2020

SERMONS IN STONES, LESSONS FROM PATHOGENS.


   It took a microscopic, invisible virus to expose the wasteful, predatory and unsustainable life style we have evolved- exposing the arrogance of a species which has been around for just about 80000 years, but has already undone most of what nature and a systematic evolution process had achieved in the millions of years which preceded it. Man is the only living thing which has the power to alter its external environment, and we have been at it, with a vengeance, ever since the Industrial Revolution-ravaging our forests, our oceans and rivers, pushing species into extinction, poisoning the air, even cluttering space with more than 5000 objects. All this in the never-ending pursuit of pleasure, convenience, gluttony and greed. Homo sapiens has been behaving as if there was no tomorrow. But the Corona virus has now shown us that ugly tomorrow- one which will be the last if we do not change our lifestyles and frenzy of consumption. Those who die of the virus may well turn out to be the lucky ones.
  The virus has so far spread to 100 countries, infected 145,000 people and killed about 4500, far less than do malaria, heart attacks, cancer, road accidents. But it has already altered our life styles and caused economic losses like no other affliction has in the past, and generated a fear not experienced before. In the coming months aviation expects to lose a hundred billion dollars, tourism eighty billion ( estimates for India are about two billion dollars if the outbreak continues till the end of the year), the cruise line industry has already lost forty billion. Global GDP growth may be halved in this fiscal. Country after country is walling itself off from the outside world, tens of millions of people have been forcibly quarantined, health infrastructures collapsing, factories at a standstill, markets and roads deserted. Tribalism is taking over. If the panic continues civil strife may not be too far off.
  Under the widening onslaught of the coronavirus the brittle layers of our "civilisation" are peeling off , one by one. This is because this was never the way nature intended us to live, nor can the planet sustain this insane consumption of natural resources- eating and drinking stuff brought from thousands of miles away, burning fuel to travel all over the world just to fill our leisure time, emitting green house gases to watch Netflix interminably instead of going out for a walk, stripping the planet's green cover just so we can build more towns, resorts, airports and golf courses. It takes a while to grasp the horrific extent of our cruelty to the planet and the demands made on it, but some figures of our depredations might help us to understand:
* Rampant non-vegetarianism. Global meat consumption is about 400 million tonnes, the per capita annual meat intake being 43 kgs. Why is this bad? Because live stock rearing accounts for 17% of total green-house gas emissions and millions of hectares of forests are being cleared to provide ranges for this livestock.
* We harvest 100 million tonnes of fish every year and 75% of fishing grounds have been exhausted. By 2025 there will be more plastic than fish in the oceans.
*  More than 6.80 billion persons travel every year for pleasure on 150,000 commercial flights every day, spewing 1.2 billion tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere.
* Every year 793 million TEUs ( Twenty feet x Twenty feet containers equivalent units) are transported across the world, carrying goods from one country to another, because of a production/ consumption mismatch.
*  The insatiable demand for energy results in the burning of 8000 million tonnes of coal every year. This figure was 4500 million in 1990.
  All of this has come at a great cost to the planet's health. 13.7 million hectares of forests are lost every year. Of the 2 million species of animal life, about 2000 are driven to extinction every year, which is about 10000 times the natural extinction rate: it is estimated that by 2070 on third of all life forms will become extinct. Recent studies have revealed 33 new microbes/ pathogens that had been locked up/ frozen in the glaciers and permafrost in the poles but could now be released because of the melting of the ice. We have no resistance to them and scientists have no idea what effect they could have on us if they become active. Water wars are just around the corner.
  Scientists have unequivocally established that the rise in zoontic diseases like Corona, Sars, Ebola, Mers, Zica, Nipah etc. are linked to the loss of biodiversity, natural habitats, and forests and climate change. Animals are coming in contact with human habitations and their bacteria and viruses are now infecting humans.The Corona virus has shown that we need  to reinvent our exploitative and inter dependent models of trade and commerce, to REDUCE and DEGLOBALISE consumption, especially of non-essential goods and products. If India had manufactured its own APIs, automobile components and smart phones, if the western world had produced its own computer chips and lithium batteries, if we ate local beef instead of importing Wagyu beef from Japan, got drunk on our own liquor instead of fixating on Scotch from Scotland or Champagne from France, vivisected our own fish instead of carting in caviar from the Caspian sea- in short, if countries had relied on local products instead of becoming over dependent on goods from China, Japan, South Korea and each other, this kind of global economic panic may not have assumed such alarming proportions. Products should be manufactured where the raw materials, essential inputs and markets are available and not where taxes are lower: the planet is more important than corporate profits. Supply chains should be local. Travel locally for pleasure and tourism, not to far away exotic destinations just because you can afford it; this has already begun to happen- a recent BBC report has revealed that in the last one month domestic tourism in Europe has gone up by 20%, even as international tourism has all but collapsed.
  Some of the beneficial effects of this Corona induced imperatives are already becoming evident: China( the world's biggest polluter) has never seen bluer skies this century, with a 25% drop in CO2 and nitrogen oxide emissions, fossil fuel consumption across the world has reduced significantly with  oil demand expected to come DOWN this year, the first time in ten years: industry sources predict that the expected demand for 2020 will be reduced by as much as 365 kilo barrels per day, back to 2011 levels. China has imposed a complete ban on all trade in wild life, and since it is the main driver of this trade, this will have a huge effect on saving many endangered species. Non-essential travel has been heavily truncated: one estimate states that between January and April this year global airline capacity fell by 40.8 million seats. As the virus continues to spread around the globe more quarantines will occur, more work outages, more flight cancellations, more production losses. Millions will face hardships, but these will have been caused as much by our unsustainable life styles and economic models as by the virus. The planet will, however, become a better place to live in, albeit temporarily.
  The corona virus crisis is where the concerns about global warming and sustainable use of natural resources converge. To overcome this virus- and others that will inevitably follow- homo sapiens will have to make fundamental changes to the way we work, eat, recreate, travel, socialise. Advances in technology can help us to make these changes: work from home instead of commuting, use skype and tele conferencing instead of jetting around the world for meetings, avoid exotic foods from far away places, eat and travel locally, do not succumb to the retail therapy of non-essential spending promoted by mindless shopping frenzies such as Black Friday, Cyber Monday or End of Reason sales. Governments should also do their bit by incentivising such behavioural changes and disincentivising practices to the contrary.
  Nature is striking back and may kill many more than the bubonic plague and the Spanish flu, primarily because of our burgeoning population and changed life styles. It is not as yet cruel, however, compared to our standards: we kill 1300 of our fellow citizens every day. So let us not blame the virus but learn to live with Nature, as our ancestors did. If we were to consider the whole thing dispassionately and clinically the corona virus is the best piece of news for planet Earth in a long time. It is not a disaster, it's a wake-up call. We can either wake up now, or hit the snooze button and go back to the neolithic age. 

10 comments:

  1. Another superlative piece from Mr Shukla... It has taken a virus to compel is to introspect on the collective harakiri that we have brought upon that we have ourselves brought upon ourselves with rampant ravage of the planet through a lifestyle that is not fueled by mere need but by collective greed! Gandhiji's foresight presaging such a doom has been conveniently ignored! 'The first past the post and the devil takes the hindmost' driven consumerism seems to have brought in the Nemesis faster than we imagined.. despite this Corona induced gloom and doom scenario and the beeline made by the super rich for the underground safe luxury bunkers in chartered planes and personal Medicare in toe all is not lost....a collective wow not to trash the learnings from this pandemic could save the day and our collective future once we acknowledge that interdependence of phenomena and oneness of life and it's environment are fundamental principles of Nature that need to be respected for our long term sustainability.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That comment was from Dr Purnima Chauhan, IAS, HP cadre

    ReplyDelete
  3. Avayji has indeed provided a graphic and tell tale account how we homo sapiens have successfully plundered the mother earth with vehemece, arrogance and total disregard of the sustainability issue of planet.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mr/ Ms Unknown/ Sir, Ma'am: which is Dr. Purnima Chauhan's comment please? Thank you, with apology for the trouble.

    "If India had manufactured its own APIs, automobile components and smart phones, if the western world had produced its own computer chips and lithium batteries, if we ate local beef instead of importing Wagyu beef from Japan, got drunk on our own liquor instead of fixating on Scotch from Scotland or Champagne from France, vivisected our own fish instead of carting in caviar from the Caspian sea- in short, if countries had relied on local products instead of becoming over dependent on goods from China, Japan, South Korea and each other, this kind of global economic panic may not have assumed such alarming proportions. Products should be manufactured where the raw materials, essential inputs and markets are available and not where taxes are lower: the planet is more important than corporate profits....Travel locally for pleasure and tourism, not to far away exotic destinations just because you can afford it......Some...beneficial effects of this Corona induced imperatives are already becoming evident: China( the world's biggest polluter) has never seen bluer skies this century, with a 25% drop in CO2 and nitrogen oxide emissions, fossil fuel consumption across the world has reduced significantly...oil demand expected to come DOWN... China has imposed a complete ban on all trade in wild life, and since it is the main driver of this trade, this will have a huge effect on saving many endangered species...Non-essential travel has been heavily truncated: one estimate states that between January and April this year global airline capacity fell by 40.8 million seats. As the virus continues to spread more quarantines will occur, more work outages, more flight cancellations, more production losses. Corona virus is where the concerns about global warming and sustainable use of natural resources converge. To overcome this...homo sapiens will have to make fundamental changes to the way we work, eat, recreate, travel, socialise...do not succumb to the retail therapy of non-essential spending promoted by mindless shopping frenzies...Nature is striking back...learn to live with Nature. If we were to consider the whole thing dispassionately and clinically the corona virus is the best piece of news for planet Earth in a long time. It is not a disaster, it's a wake-up call..."
    These lines bear repetition for actual sinking in. It's the real message, not from Mr Shukla, but through him. Hence the copy-paste. That we may heed and understand and bring about.
    The rest, as they say, is said.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mr mustafi the very first comment station with the words 'another superlative... Are my comments..rgds Purnima

      Delete
  5. I wish people who really matter could heed to such alarms. Well said Sir.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Where Gurus failed, Pathogens delivered.
    Climate Challenge will be solved by pathogens and not by IPCC.
    Most of the climate change challenge arises out of lifestyle and changed way of living. Planet earth still has enough for living a normal decent life. Thought that the lifestyle and way of living are guided by religion but never thought that we all changed our religion to that of one religion – mindless competitive consumerism - always trying to be one up with the Joneses; And certainly not in competition for any good deed. Governments have to run IEC programmes to teach us the good ways which should have come naturally to us. But now it turns out that pathogens, viruses and other contagions are better teachers than best of IECs or religious gurus. Thanks Corona, Ebola, Nipah et al.
    There are many problems but for the purpose here following three should suffice.
    First problem is with the very definition of ‘Civilized’. The recognition as ’civilized’ came and got measured in term of distance one was away from ‘nature’. Homo sapiens left forests and natural settings for various reasons and called themselves civilized. Now, it turns out this is the most uncivil thing humans ever did. And not being satisfied with tag of mere civilized, some took to being Elite. The Elite cannot exist without obscene consumptions. This elitism became new path to follow for the blinds described later.
    Second problem is Blindness. The distance between production areas (read nature’s ruthless exploitation areas) and consumption areas has caused blindness among consumers, while the pain was (and is) felt by those living in production areas. The day an innocent urban child told that the colour of the sky is grey and that the milk comes from dispensing machine, the story was complete. The sufferings in production areas has been sought to be alleviated through financial and economic palliatives. Philosophy is flawed. There is hardly serious enough effort at real healing, firstly by judicious extraction and secondly by restoring the nature. Blinds drive governments mad and the businesses to salivate.
    Third problem is Growth. World over businesses follow cheap resources and cheap labour. Both are found in poverty stricken areas. These are also the areas where government presence is either minimal or have worst forms of governance. It suits both – businesses and governments. They both are perpetually dissatisfied with the achievements made previously and want ‘growth’, growth and more growth. So long as businesses and governments continue to chase growth statistics, the problem, far from being addressed, will continue to multiply. Now is the time, we relearn the good old philosophy. A homeostasis once achieved need not be disturbed.
    IPCC is doing good job but not a great job. If we see the environmental success of COVID-2019, IPCC’s efforts pale into insignificance. It should learn from microbes than from human giants. Lest nature sends newer pathogens, humans should readjust to living with nature bearing in mind Chief Seattle's famous saying 'we belong to the earth, earth doesn’t belong to us'.
    If we still refuse to learn our lessons and continue to chase statistics, Gaia will balance the numbers. If we do not hear the warning shots, it will fire its canons.
    Let us wake up.
    Let us try to live with the minimum and not the maximum.

    ReplyDelete
  7. wait a minute, on second thought, has nature found that we are the pathogens that it needs to eliminate to sustain the planet?

    ReplyDelete