Add this

Sunday, 10 August 2025

WHEN ONLY LOVE REMAINS

 I have just returned from my hometown, Kanpur, after severing the last remaining physical link with my late parents, with the tangible legacies of my dad and mom. My mother passed away in 1994, my dad joined her in 2017. He left behind a lovely flat in a multi-story development, in which he had spent the last years of his life, lonely most of the time, but content and at peace in his otherwise downsized world.

This flat contained the possessions he and my mom, and we (as children), had accumulated over the years, and not one of them was less than fifty years old! These included British time crockery, a Garrard music player with vinyl records, hundreds of books (mostly mine), furniture from Calcutta and Assam, an assortment of walking sticks. He had hoarded them lovingly, getting them cleaned and polished regularly, for would his children not inherit them some day? They were precious to him, not just because he had laboured to acquire them over a lifetime, but because they would go to his children after him.

That was never going to happen, of course. The flat was being sold, and we all had enough bric-a-brac of our own, accumulated over our own lifetimes, for our own children! Where was the space to take over my dad's stuff in our metro flats in Mumbai and Noida, where each square foot of space cost Rs. 100,000 and  Rs. 10000/-, respectively? So we gave everything away- the records whose music had once suffused the flat with lilting tunes, the books which had made holidays in Kanpur so pleasant and relaxed, the table at which I had prepared for the civil service exams, the dining table on which my mom used to serve the delicious "atta ka halwa" and "gobhi ki subzi" which were, and still are, my favourite fare, the harmonium on which my late younger sister learned her music. All big slices of our past, all indelibly associated with my mom and dad and our childhood. All now gone. I have retained only a few books, one of Papa's walking sticks, his battered briefcase, and a set of crystal Johnnie Walker glasses, which I had bought for fifteen rupees from the Jama Masjid Sunday market in 1971 and had gifted him for his birthday. They will have to suffice till I retain my memory of him.

The compulsions of "modern" life have no time for the sentiments of the past, these are weaknesses that detract from our algorithm based, market driven vision of a material valhalla. And that precisely is the point of this blog: there is a lesson in my experience, for all of us, all those adrift in the 70+ boat, most of us in sight of the harbour, or the reef, as fate would have it. As parents we spend too much time, resources and emotional capital, and deny ourselves, in collecting things to leave behind for our children. It's a waste of parental love, a mortgaging of  present needs for an envisioned but uncertain future. For nothing we leave behind will endure- the house will be sold (if not fought over), the money in the bank will be divided ruthlessly by some chartered accountant or lawyer and spent on trips to Bali or Biarritz, the clothes will go to charity, everything else will be given away. Nothing will remain but memories, and it is on those that we twilight dwellers should concentrate.. I am reminded of these haunting lines from an anonymous poet:

If I take nothing with me,                                                                                                            May I leave behind something beautiful-                                                                                    A memory, a kindness, a warmth in the hearts of those I've met.                                                So that, even when my road ends,                                                                                                Love remains.

POST SCRIPT.

I make it a point never to end any piece on a somber note, lest the reader fling himself off his 22nd floor balcony in despair; and so I must confess that I did take one other object from my dad's flat- the album of photographs of my marriage with Neerja. (That was in 1977, I think, but I can't be sure since my long term memory is no longer what it used to be). There were no digital albums in those primordial days, no smart phones; only "still" photos which had to be pasted in bulky albums. I've appropriated my wedding album, not just for sentimental reasons, but as an abundant precaution to prove my marriage with Neerja. In these days of "certificate raj" there is no saying when proof will be demanded that I am not living in sin with her. Hotels and OYO have already started demanding this, and the time is not far off when banks, landlords and RWAs shall follow suit. "Marriage vigilantism" will be the latest addition to cow and citizenship vigilantisms. Didn't someone say that eternal vigilantism is the price of freedom? Better to be prepared, no?

But I'm taking a big risk bringing this album home and reminding Neerja about our marriage. She has had many second thoughts about these nuptials over the last 48 years, about the wisdom of having plighted her troth to me in an LSR moment of weakness. How will she react to my bringing home documented proof of what she sometimes considers the "biggest mistake of her life"? Maybe I'll hide the album under the dog's bed. As they say in the Pakistan Punjab - "Better to be Saif than Suri."


12 comments:

  1. Beautifully sensitive and most appealing piece. Reminds me of my parents and the love that remains. As age advances my 'association' with them grows. Thanks for articulating MY sentiments!

    ReplyDelete
  2. We use West Punjab or Lehnda Punjab as opposed to our side’s East Punjab or Chardha Punjab.

    ReplyDelete
  3. If this comment reaches Mr. Shukla, it means he is reading a posthumous post, for one has flung oneself in despair from the 22nd floor upon reading his latest blog.
    Until the poetic ode to love and memories, the smile was beatific, the eyes moist, the mind tranquil. Then came the jolt — disturbing to one who places a premium upon the troth.
    Mr. Shukla has had to retain albumic, photographic proof of his coupling with the missus, forty eight years after they plighted their troth!
    What will be one’s plight when, still two decades short of his tenure, one will gather evidences — material, digital, even artificially intelligent — to persuade the better half of her matrimony, as he now feels compelled to do?
    They say in the hinterlands of Punjab, "…better to be poofed than proofed..."
    It is with these devastating thoughts that one finishes this post, as the elevator ascends to the top floor…

    ReplyDelete
  4. What a lovely article you have penned Shukla Saab! Keep enthralling your readers again and again

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nostalgia and emotions that we go through as we see life happen ,memories and moments that mean so much ..looking back at the journey called life and the road travelled

    ReplyDelete
  6. A lovely piece Sir! A bit maudlin, essentially realistic and finally humorous too! As we approach your vintage, our thoughts turn towards our roots as well as our children's future. I guess the closing lines of that poem will serve as our lodestone. Look forward to more from your pen...err. keyboard.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sensitive and so very apt. You've articulated a reality which all of us over 70 are aware of, faced with and have to accept as the way of the new world which used to be so very different in the time of our parents when every little possession was treasured and nurtured.
    Oh yes! The world HAS not just changed, its been turned upside down and we're all at the receiving end of it. I do, at times, wonder what the future holds for us and more so, for our progeny.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sir,
    Elderly Indians are generally rich in their cemetary*..their entire life is spent upon building, amassing and piling assets which they hardly use for themselves. Ironically, its all left behind.
    *Mehmood Saab ka ek gaana yaad aa gaya - Kal kya hoga kisko pata abhi zindagi ka le lo mazaa*
    Through your article, can easily foresee future of our accumulation.. don't need a astrolger

    ReplyDelete
  9. Agree, Mr Jha. What's the point in being the richest corpse in the cemetery?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sir,
    Your article is a meditative piece born out of loss, regret, and deep self-questioning. You poignantly describe the bittersweet task of dismantling your father’s tangible legacy and reflect on the futility of accumulating material things for the sake of posterity. In your writing, you do not merely lament the disposal of your father’s belongings or a lack of attachment to memory; rather, you highlight the broader human tendency to focus on things instead of cherishing love and shared time. Your message about what truly survives after we are gone—the warmth of love, not the weight of things—is both powerful and important.

    At the same time, I believe there is another perspective to consider. Your father’s (and indeed anyone’s) possessions were primarily about living well in his own way, enjoying life, and fulfilling personal desires—not necessarily about leaving a legacy for his son or others. The real purpose of these belongings was personal joy, comfort, and meaning—something every individual is entitled to cultivate within their own home and heart.

    Thank you for sharing such an honest and thought-provoking reflection. It has given me much to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  11. शुक्ला सर। आपका लेख पढ़कर दिल पसीज गया। बेहतरीन लेखनी। साधुवाद। मित्रों के साथ साझा करने की अनुमति दीजिये।

    ReplyDelete
  12. Please convey my request to Mrs. Neerja ji to forgive you for your indiscretion to safe -keep the irrefutable testimony of your marriage with her , the photo album

    ReplyDelete